I'm an idiot. I removed the cotton and left the foam baffles. I had bass.
LOL, what was I even thinking. Thanks Thujone, I'm going to remove the cotton right now and see where it gets me. I'll just have to get carpet tape or something to make sure the foam baffle doesn't fall out. :)
edit: I HAVE BASS, THUJONE AND BLUEMONKEYFLYER YOU'RE BOTH THE BEST, WOOO!
This made me lol. I'm glad you got the rumblies back in your ears