And here are the replacement shields I got, after not being 100% happy with the ones I got before!
I must say they turned out quite a bit better this time around. I wouldn't say they're 100% perfect - and for some reason I noticed that one side was off-white and the other was a more natural white? At any rate, the lines are smooth and it's pretty crisp! I find that near the edges of the shields it starts to get a little less defined, but it's not enough for me to demand another replacement, I felt that I was being a bit picky even the first time. :P
Anyway, I'm pretty happy with these now!
(and yes, that is a raichu)