Quote:
Originally Posted by
HeroicPenguin 
No idea why honestly (since I'm on Head-Fi, so I'm somewhat confused too). I guess reviewers are more about just listening to music for enjoyment rather than analyzing things that in depth. Reviewing for me tends to be more of a emotional response than an analytical one; it's about how I feel about the music. I don't care if it's technically proficient if I don't feel anything. That's my take at least. People here listen to their gear; critics (hopefully) listen to the music.
But, getting better equipment certainly helps enjoyment.
And now that I think about this a bit more, it really depends on whether the Music Critic is commenting on the performance & music OR the performance, music and recording quality.
(I'm sure any Head Fi-er uses decent equipment.)
I think would be irritated if read a review where critic said "This new album from XYZ band is fantastic, the writing is fantastic, they have never played better and the recording quality is first rate", then I found out that the critic was listening to music on Brand X el cheapo equipment. If the guy uses El Cheapo equipment, that's OK by me, just don't comment on the recording quality.
Anyway...................just my take on it.