Quote:
Originally Posted by
skamp 
Maybe you could trust him as far as the Koss Porta Pros are concerned, since that's the only pair of headphones that he used while tuning the TP. But how can you trust him with completely different headphones / IEMs that he did not test and that might not react the same way at all?
Also, why would I trust him to begin with? I don't know him. It's not like he has a serious reputation or any authority in the industry.
Be patient to read my story...
I didn't know Jadis' designer, I did not know Linn's CD 12 detail design but I know I had more than 10 years (with the Jadis) and 8 years (with the Linn CD 12) ownership. I did not even bother to looking at the spec but just love the music. The system was so good that one buyer came in to my home 2 years ago (when I was trying to sell my CD12 to him) and at the end he took my whole system away...the music did the magic.
I had the luxury, before the time I acquired the Jadis (JPS2S+JA100), to have different dealers lend me Audio Research, Krell, Jadis (can't remember another Italian brand valve amp) to test out at my home and ultimately I've found the valved amp performed the best (against the Krell that I used to have, Class A amp). I did not even looking at the advertising leaflets that they gave me but to determine which one is best for me, with my ears.
Absolutely correct that no one would ever know the chemical result for plugging one device with another equipment and what the end result would come out until you've tried. I went through this journey many many times over the course of 10 years that I owned my previous systems with different power cords, but not inter-connectors nor speaker cables (as I've got it right the very first time, lucky me).
Apparently in this forum, a lot of fellow head fiers owned multi devices and earphones. With their collections, I bet not every combination would work as well as the other ...you win some and loose some. This is one addiction of this hobby...there are always be variables.
Whether you trust Charles or not, any other brand designers, 3rd party reviewers, it is not important. Reviewers can only review equipment with the system that they owned. Each component plugs into ones system generates different result and, it needs to suit the reviewer's taste. The reviewer's reports just for leisure reading to occupy our hi fiers' time, nothing more. Ultimately, what you'd hear and it counts...as the only performance begins at the time you plug that new acquisition into your "system" and play...where music starts.
Before I decided on the TP, I spent weeks on the AK 100 forum to go through those hundred of pages and...came up with one opportunity in December...I spent 2 hours testing out my Sony PCM D50 against the AK100, side-by-side, with the same songs, over and over again, and decision was made... I've then move on [from the AK100 forum]...to make time for my music while awaiting the TP delivery.
Hope you'd enjoy more music rather than visual charts. That would make you a happy person.