I haven't really enjoyed many survival horror or post-apoc games. Fallout sucked, L4D got tired really quick, Dead Island was repetitive, STALKER series was dull and tedious but the plot was decent...etc
I liked Amnesia: Dark Descent and Dead Space 1+2. Those are the only modern games in those two categories I think I liked.
Basically, I think the entire genre sucks.
Dead Island was quite repetetive