Head-Fi.org › Forums › Summit-Fi (High-End Audio) › High-end Audio Forum › Electrostatic Amplifiers Voltage ratings
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Electrostatic Amplifiers Voltage ratings

post #1 of 29
Thread Starter 

I get asked about this fairly often, there are a number of different ways of measuring the voltages

so here in one place is all the amps i know about, and all are rated the same.  The voltage is

peak to peak voltage measured from one stator to the other stator.

 

For solid state amplifiers, the output voltage is usually very close to the power supply rails.

For OTL tube amplifiers, the Rp of the output tube(s) usually takes about 60 volts off of the

maximum voltage swing, for Stax made amplifiers the negative power supply is increased to

compensate for this. These are theoretical maximums, in practice the voltage swing will be less.

 

There is of course more to these amplifiers than just the voltage ratings, Slew rate into a

capactive load is also very important, i will be measuring some of these amplifiers and will

add slew rate at a later time.

 

3000 volts peak to peak stator to stator (+/-750 power supplies)

KG TOGTE

 

2400 volts peak to peak stator to stator (+/-600 power supplies)

koss esp950

 

2300 volts peak to peak stator to stator (+/-575 power supplies)

KG’s new Silicon Carbide jfet based space heater.

 

2000 volts peak to peak stator to stator  (+/-500 power supplies)

Stax T2, DIY T2, KGSSHV (ixys parts)

 

1800 volts peak to peak stator to stator (+/-450 power supplies)

KGSSHV (sanyo parts)

craig has said his new electra amp does 1800 volts, power supply unknown

Ergo Jecklin

 

1600 volts peak to peak stator to stator (+/-400 power supplies)

BH, BHSE, singlepower ES1,ESX (after being modified to remove the 100V offset)

Cavalli Audio Liquid Lightning

 

1400 volts peak to peak stator to stator  (+/-350 power supplies)

KGSS,Stax T1,T1s,T1W,313,323,717,727,sra-14s,srm-1 mk2,srm-monitor

woo audio wes

 

1300 volts peak to peak  stator to stator

stax sra-10s/12s

 

1200 volts peak to peak (+/-300 power supplies, and +600 capacitively coupled)

KG tube #1,aristaeus,HEV70,HEV90,RSA A10,srm300,Exstata

Egmont,Cirolan,SRM-1,srm-3,woo audio ges,srm310

 

1100 volts peak to peak stator to stator

stax sra-3s

stax srm-001 (when the batterys are at full power)

 

1000 volts peak to peak (+/-260 volt power supplies)

Rudistor Egmont

 

960 volts peak to peak stator to stator

Stax srmXh, srm212

 

540 volts peak to peak stator to stator

Very early HEV70  (+525 volt power supply and tubes biased at 390 volts)

 

 

More added later

 

 

edited 5/3/12 for clarity and fixed srmXh,srm212

added a couple of others


Edited by kevin gilmore - 6/14/12 at 6:20pm
post #2 of 29

Thanks for posting this, KG.

post #3 of 29

Thanks a lot, Kelvin.  :)

 

Wachara C.

post #4 of 29

Thanks a lot.

Looking forward for the Slew Rate measurements too. :)

post #5 of 29

Thanks so much Kevin

How much does the voltage swing influence the performance of the electrostatic

amplifier?  Are there any other factors?

post #6 of 29

When my email starts working again then KG will have an updated list to post.  smily_headphones1.gif

 

It's should also be noted that while voltage swing is important, it is only one aspect of an amplifiers performance.  It also says nothing about the load tolerance of the amp or how far into Class A the output stage is biased. 

 

While most of these amps will never see anything close to their full voltage swing in normal use, they have enough voltage on tap to destroy the electrostatic transducers.  Some are more sensitive than others (Stax normal bias, Sennheiser HE90) but this is a real issue given enough input voltage and high enough gain. 

post #7 of 29

Not that it really matters, but I'm curious why you chose peak to peak  rather than rms output voltage. Stax uses rms in their product descriptions. Seems this has caused a good deal of confusion here in the past.

 

Appreciate the info and look forward to your slew rate measurements. I'm also curious about the current levels in the output stages of the amps.

post #8 of 29

Well peak-to-peak has become a bit of an industry standard in the DIY world with only Stax using RMS.  Still it is easy enough to convert, RMS*1.41*2 to get the P-P value.  The SRM-300(310) is listed at 350VRMS so that would be roughly 1000V P-P.  Stax always post conservative specs plus these are measured, not simply derived from the rail voltages (in this case +600V regulated). 

post #9 of 29
Thread Starter 

Here are some of the output stage currents. Remember that every single amplifier has balanced outputs, so

there are actually 4 output stages. The new eddiecurrent thing probably has output transformers, so its different.

 

kgss  8.3 ma x 4

kgsshv 5.5ma x 4  (you can turn it up if you have lots of heatsink)

T2 14ma x 4

ES1/ESX  8.5ma x 4  (when its modified to work correctly) (if you change out the plate resistors with current sources, up to 20ma x 4)

kg tube amp #1, aristaeus and hev90  6.3 ma x 4

kg silicon carbide space heater  50ma x 4

koss es950  1ma x 4

BH,BHSE  18ma x 4

 

most of the other stax tube amps are about 7.5 ma x 4

srm313,srm323  5.5ma x 4

srm717,srm727 6.6ma x 4

 

 

 

The rest i will have to look up later.

post #10 of 29

Whoa, the KGSCSH is a beast - higher output voltage than T2 and 3.5 times the output stage current?!!

post #11 of 29

depending on the devices used output bias current may be largley used just charging/discharging the semi device output C - easily as much or more C than the ES headphone (ES headphone + cable C is ~100 pF)

 

and larger current as substantially more dangerous - 50 mA is above the tetanous threshold for AC, near the DC threshold for women = when the muscle contractions are so severe you can't let go

 

post #12 of 29

I assume he is using one of the semisouth SiC jfets

post #13 of 29
Thread Starter 

Technology is driven by demand these days, not the other way around.

The silicon carbide devices are very new, and designed for use in

huge solar panel arrays. The devices are designed for up to 25 amps

and just happen to be good for 1200+ volts. I doubt that lower

current devices with a much more narrow channel and much lower

capacitance will ever show up because there is no need for them.

Great for guys like Nelson Pass whose monster power amps are going

to love these things. For electrostatic amps, 400 watts of standing

power is a bit over the top.  You won't see me releasing a circuit

board for this unit. Besides which the energy storage of the power

supply is over 2000 joules.

post #14 of 29



 

Quote:
Originally Posted by kevin gilmore View Post

Here are some of the output stage currents. Remember that every single amplifier has balanced outputs, so

there are actually 4 output stages. The new eddiecurrent thing probably has output transformers, so its different.

 

kgss  8.3 ma x 4

kgsshv 5.5ma x 4  (you can turn it up if you have lots of heatsink)

T2 14ma x 4

ES1/ESX  8.5ma x 4  (when its modified to work correctly) (if you change out the plate resistors with current sources, up to 20ma x 4)

kg tube amp #1, aristaeus and hev90  6.3 ma x 4

kg silicon carbide space heater  50ma x 4

koss es950  1ma x 4

BH,BHSE  18ma x 4

 

most of the other stax tube amps are about 7.5 ma x 4

srm313,srm323  5.5ma x 4

srm717,srm727 6.6ma x 4

 

 

 

The rest i will have to look up later.


I'm a little bit surprised by the relatively low currents here and would think that they would dramatically  impact slew rate in a negative manner.  What kind of slew rates are considered acceptable? If slew rate equals 2piFVp/1000000, and you use 20kHz and 500Vp as your target points,SR equals 68V per microsecond.  Current should equal SRxC. The SR009 has a capacitance of 110pf. Using this value, looks like you need  a minimum of about 7mA. in the output stage. Of course I'm just "parroting" (or 'misparroting") Broskie here.
 

On a purely subjective level,using the very basic Egmont circuit, increased output stage current levels seem to correlate to a higher sound quality.

 

post #15 of 29

Thanks KG, interesting information and useful information,

 

I am going to put the parts together for (your) KGSSHV but I thinks the silicon carbine part might not available commercially in Thailand as yet! any suggestion?

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: High-end Audio Forum
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Summit-Fi (High-End Audio) › High-end Audio Forum › Electrostatic Amplifiers Voltage ratings