Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › NC heaphones in comparison. Newbie need some help
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

NC heaphones in comparison. Newbie need some help

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 

Firstable, let me introduce myself quickly.

My name is Christopher, 21 years old, and english isn't my first ( or second ) language. I come from belgium and subscribed to this website because it looked so full of information. I studied english so i should be able to reply correctly and understand your comments.

 

I'm looking, recently, for a headphone that will isolate me from the outside.
I'm a regular poker players and sometimes i need quite in those room full of people talking BUT i'm firstable a student and i would like something to help me study in stilness (i'm sharing a room in a house full of students ).

I also travel a lot, mostly with the bus or railway but i take the plane quite often to.

 

My budget goes around 220euros ( 300dollars top ).

 

I have looked for those headphones:

 

 

Audio technica ANC7b ( heard that they have major soud leakage problem, true ? ).

Bose QC15: way over my budget but not out of option

 

Sony MDRNC 60

 

Bose AE2: not active noise cancelling but super comfortable

Monster beats studio: heard a lot of bashing arounf them, don't really care about the style

 

Sennheiser HD280 pro

 

......

 

Not to mention they need to be very comfortable ;)

 

What should i choose ( or NOT choose ). Other suggestion ?( i still can look on amazon ).
I welcome every commentary and hope my english was fine enough for you guys!

 

See you soon

 

post #2 of 10

Hi Fedec,

 

Here are my two cents as an owner of the ATH-ANC7b. They work great in airplanes, but for other everyday environments might be a bit overkill. For your needs, why don't you try some in-ear noise-cancelling buds?

 

For additional info, I also auditioned the Dr Dre Beats and the Bose Quiet Comfort 15 and two of my colleagues own them, so when we fly together we exchange cans for a while to check them out. I do not like the sound of the Beats at all. They are exciting, but emphasize the bass way too much and are very expensive. The Boses do a fine job on less dynamic stuff, but from your age, I'm guessing the Bose will struggle to match your music collection. They also generate a lot of pressure on the ears to create the noise-cancelling effect. Much more than the ANC7b. You should audition the Bose QC15 and then you'll know what i'm describing.

 

In conclusion, I can really recomment the ATH-ANC7b, but think you might want to give in-ear noise-cancelling buds a try. They also are probably better for studying, because all over the ear headphones get warm after a while. The ANC7b's are really comfy but get warm too and they do leak a noticeable amount of sound.

post #3 of 10
Thread Starter 

Waouw that was a quick answer. Thanks :)

 

I enjoyed your point of view over the ANC7b.

About the noise cancelling bud, i tried some and i'm not huge fan of them, they hurted after long use...
About the kind of music i listen, it's mostly :


Jamiroquai, Queen, tricky, Björk, MGMT, Daft punk, the killers, Muse, Michael Jackson ...
No so much Hip Hop and even less rap.

Classic sometime.

 

 

post #4 of 10
Thread Starter 

Sorry for the double post.

 

What do you mean by "overkill"?

 

What earbuds do you suggest that have the best noise cancelling And are comfortable ( i tried the sennheiser cx300 ) and they are fine but heart after a while and cancel the noise only a little IMO.

post #5 of 10


 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fedec View Post

Sorry for the double post.

 

What do you mean by "overkill"?

 

What earbuds do you suggest that have the best noise cancelling And are comfortable ( i tried the sennheiser cx300 ) and they are fine but heart after a while and cancel the noise only a little IMO.



I tried to reply and the post got lost, so let's try that again

 

By overkill, I mean that the ATH-ANC7b could be much more than you actually require and cost more than you need to spend.

The Sennheiser CX300 is probably only noise-isolating, not noise-cancelling. Noise-cancelling earphones come with a plstic unit which houses the battery compartment and circuit which produces the noise-cancelling effect. Check out the

Audio-Technica ATH ANC23  and Pioneer SE-NC31C-K

post #6 of 10
Thread Starter 

I understand.

I've already read some intersting reviews over the pioneer and audio technica. You're right, the earbuds that i use are probably noise isolating.
I'm still a little concerned about the "in ear" noise cancelling system ( don't know how to call it else ). Looks unhealthy... And not so much comfortable.
Have you tried them?

I still did other research ( i'm a little stubborn sorry ), and found other intersting headphones:

 

Sony MDR-NC60 and the Denon AHNC-800.

post #7 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fedec View Post

I understand.

I've already read some intersting reviews over the pioneer and audio technica. You're right, the earbuds that i use are probably noise isolating.
I'm still a little concerned about the "in ear" noise cancelling system ( don't know how to call it else ). Looks unhealthy... And not so much comfortable.
Have you tried them?

I still did other research ( i'm a little stubborn sorry ), and found other intersting headphones:

 

Sony MDR-NC60 and the Denon AHNC-800.


The ATH-ANC23 is quite comfortable for me and I actually like in-ear buds, but the noise-cancelling on that  model is not great.

I'm not familiar with the two models you've listed - Sony MDR-NC60 and the Denon AHNC-800. - my suggestion is to find a store that allows you to audition them.

Sony noise-cancelling products can be very good or very mediocre.

 

Oh.....and never apologize for doing your own research :)

post #8 of 10

I forgot to tell you that no matter which NC headphone you choose, make sure that the ear pads surround your ears completely. If you have big ears, this might be a bit tricky.

The reason is that otherwise a bit of pressure is produced and listening to the cans for a long time can be a bit challenging. However, if they sit right, you can hear for extended periods in isolated bliss :)

post #9 of 10

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fedec View Post

Firstable, let me introduce myself quickly.

My name is Christopher, 21 years old, and english isn't my first ( or second ) language. I come from belgium and subscribed to this website because it looked so full of information. I studied english so i should be able to reply correctly and understand your comments.

 

I'm looking, recently, for a headphone that will isolate me from the outside.
I'm a regular poker players and sometimes i need quite in those room full of people talking BUT i'm firstable a student and i would like something to help me study in stilness (i'm sharing a room in a house full of students ).

I also travel a lot, mostly with the bus or railway but i take the plane quite often to.

 

My budget goes around 220euros ( 300dollars top ).

 

I have looked for those headphones:

 

 

Audio technica ANC7b ( heard that they have major soud leakage problem, true ? ).

Bose QC15: way over my budget but not out of option

 

Sony MDRNC 60

 

Bose AE2: not active noise cancelling but super comfortable

Monster beats studio: heard a lot of bashing arounf them, don't really care about the style

 

Sennheiser HD280 pro

 

......

 

Not to mention they need to be very comfortable ;)

 

What should i choose ( or NOT choose ). Other suggestion ?( i still can look on amazon ).
I welcome every commentary and hope my english was fine enough for you guys!

 

See you soon

 



I had Bose QC15 for a while (Birthday present from a friend) first I thought they sounded good, noise cancelling is great but later I realize they sound so tiny compare to other headphones, not work well with every genre of music, also gave me headache from pressure of active NC, I think it's not good for human ear to listing to it for long time with that much of pressure. So I sold it on eBay and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.

just my .02 cents.


Edited by Tharbamar - 11/20/11 at 1:26am
post #10 of 10
I would suggest getting closed back headphones. I don't really think active noise canceling would help much in your situation.
You could look into the HD 25-1 II, a bit below your budget but still excellent cans in my opinion. They have quite a bit of isolation, and I use them to suppress the volume of other people's conversations all the time.
The only thing I'd be worried with these cans is that they can get a bit uncomfortable if you listen with them for long times. This might be less with the velour ear pads, but I haven't tried those.

You can get them for 172 euros over at bax-shop.
On a semi-related note: are you Flemish or Walloon?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Headphones (full-size)
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › NC heaphones in comparison. Newbie need some help