Here's something different. Highly rated headphones I absolutely hated in every way:
ESW9a (Mids. What mids? Too warm and too much bass bleed)
D1100 - First headphone that made me shout obscenities with disgust. I rarely swear too.
Grado SR-325i - Painful treble, but they deserve a second chance, but it'll never happen. Will try 225 instead.
HD-497 - my longest owned headphone and I hate every rotten thing about them.