I'm in an un-decisive state right now. I'm currently switching between an Audio-gd NFB-2 and an Ultra-Fi DAC 41 (which is Larry Moore's next generation of the Tranquility, but he's gone in a slightly different direction than Eric Hider at dB Audiolabs - but that's a whole other story...).
Anyway, now I have an opportunity to buy a used Octave. But for about 50% more I could get the new MKII. Anyone have any experiences they could share comparing these DACs?
The NFB-2 and DAC 41 both have their strengths and weaknesses. The DAC 41 is a NOS DAC limited to 44.1/16, but this doesn't seem to be a problem at all. It's smoother, it has more detail, more air, instrument separation and it's more 3 dimensional. But it has less dynamic punch, everything is kind of smoothed out and sightly homogenized. It's like when you hear a mix that's TOO perfect, it lacks the strong sharp peaks and the warm, deep valleys. Don't mistake this for dynamic range, it has great range, it's the impact and quickness, or lack thereof. This is a big problem for me, because while the NFB-2 is inferior in every other way, it does have that impact and in the end it's sounding more realistic to me. I haven't given up on the DAC 41, there are some things I need to play with first.
But now the Octave comes on my radar and from what I can glean from this thread and reviews, it sound like it's exactly what I'm looking for. If I had the $$ I'd probably just go for the Audio-gd Master 7. BTW, anyone compare the Master 7 to the Hex?
I might be able to justify the cost of the MkII, but as others have pointed out, it may not be worth the extra cost. But here's something to consider: The MkII with the upgraded USB receiver should have more inherent quality potential than an Octave with a DI. I have the Stello U3, so I'm set there. But these boxes put you into S/PDIF which, from what I've read, is not as good an interface as a well implemented USB interface. So no matter what, with the Octave you are stuck with S/PDIF.
And then you have to wonder if that's really an issue considering that Cees himself says there's only a slight difference. I'd like to hear a comparison of the MkII via upgraded USB and the MkII with a Stello to S/PDIF. Then how much of a difference would there be?