Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphone Amps (full-size) › Hifiman EF5 -- modded by K Works
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Hifiman EF5 -- modded by K Works

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 

A couple of years ago I discovered a one-man audio company in New Jersey called K Works (Igor Kuznetsoff). I purchased some of his products, and discovered they are really, really great for my tastes.

 

These days I use headphones exclusively. In the past I have owned several headphone amps. I've heard and owned several capacitor-coupled SET designs, including the Zen Little Buddy and the Wheatfield HA-2. However I really fell in love with SET when I heard a classic implementation of it, the DNA Sonett. (By classic I mean relatively simple design and transformer-coupled output.)

 

But always interested in “the new,” I asked Igor at K Works if he had ever heard a headphone amp that really grabbed him. For another customer, he did a recent custom modification of the Hifiman EF5 and it worked out very well. Let me explain what the EF5 is. It's a hybrid amp with a 12AU7 input stage, and a solid-state output stage that uses an op amp and some discrete transistors. It's VERY high-power for a headphone amp (probably several watts) and that is by design: Hifiman produced this amp to drive its inefficient orthodynamic headphones such as the HE6LE. It drives the K1000 easily. But the amp works just fine with common-variety dynamic headphones.

 

Igor knows I LOVE good dynamics, and he said the stock EF5 had explosive dynamics. It's only $400 from Audio Advisor, so I ordered one. Using it with the AKG K601 headphone, the crispness and definition of transients (like leading edges of instrumental attack) were stunning. Instruments and inner voices were clearly separated. But, it was a bit over-eager, presenting transients with too much emphasis, and could get very raucous in big orchestral climaxes. It also was weak in musical emotion compared to my DNA Sonett (the classic SET I mentioned above).

 

But, Igor explained that it was a really good value, with high-quality parts and sophisticated power regulation. It just had a few weaknesses in parts and design that could be easily remedied.

 

So I took the plunge and commissioned Igor to mod it. Mainly he planned to upgrade the power supply, the capacitors, the op amps, and internal wires. He didn't put in a fancy volume pot (there's hardly any room in the chassis). He probably did other stuff too. Basically I trusted him to do the most important things. The mod was $1600 (so plus the $400 for the amp, total cost was $2000), although I hesitate to mention this number because this sort of job can be extremely variable in cost and I don't want anyone to assume this is what he would charge for a similar mod in the future.

 

I got the finished EF5 a few weeks ago, and I've tried it with both the AKG K601 and K701. (As a side note, I discovered that the K601 needs a little series impedance with the output to take the edge off its tendency to fatiguing highs—about 20 to 30 ohms removes that fatiguing quality beautifully well.)

 

This amp just explodes with musical feeling. It presents details and dynamics with high resolution, but it does more than that. To the extent it magnifies the resolution, it also magnifies the musical feeling. If, on a particular recording, it has ten times the perceived resolution of other amps I've heard—then it also has ten times the musical feeling of other amps I've heard.

 

This is not such an obvious point. I've heard lots of equipment that is detailed but without much musical feeling. Say I doing an experiment by comparing two devices, A and B. And I decide that B has more resolution, but not more musical feeling. This is common. In fact that's my opinion of the comparison between the K601 and K701—the K701 has something like four times the resolution and imaging capability, but no extra musical feeling. Maybe even less musical feeling.

 

My modded EF5 presents musical feeling with absolute clarity. Tragic music is intensely tragic, joyful music is intensely joyful. There's also a type of musical feeling that doesn't really fit categories like “tragic” or “joyful”--it's the passion that one senses in the swelling and ebbing of the dynamics. In the modded EF5, this passion is so intense that I couldn't possibly miss it.

 

If you were 90% in a coma and just minutes away from death, but somehow I got you to listen to passionate music on this EF5, and just a tiny bit of that sonic signal reached your consciousness, you would feel it. It's that clear.

 

In describing the passion in the dynamics, the technical term “microdynamics” is useful. This term describes how clearly the equipment presents small dynamic changes. Small dynamic changes may be small, but in classical music (and other types) they are a powerful source of musical feeling. It's not enough that my amp tells me analytically the loudness level is changing—I must FEEL the effect of this change. And that's what the modded EF5 does.

 

It also has good treble extension, so that instruments are much higher-resolution. Say you're listening to a string quartet. You can hear all the subtle modulations of attack and tonal quality. But I have to say again—you FEEL these modulations. It's not enough to hear them. One must feel them.

 

It has good bass extension, detail, and especially IMPACT and POWER. You can't really feel headphone bass in your body, but you can potentially tell how deep and powerful a drum is, or hear the nuances in tonal quality on a stringed bass.

 

It makes the musicians sound like better musicians. That's a litmus test for me. If listening to a familiar recording on a new device (be it amp, DAC, power conditioner, etc.) makes me think, “I didn't realize before how good the musicians are,” then I know I've found something special.

 

In the photo below, you see the power supply and amp. The stock volume knob was tiny and had nearly invisible markings, so I had K Works replace it with a skirted knob and clear markings. The little box at the end of the gold cable adds variable series resistance to the output, which turns out to be critical for getting the best sound from AKG headphones. The amp main box is sitting on pneumatic isolation feet (not part of the stock amp).

 

Finished amp

 

A view of the internals. At the back you can see a strip of ERS paper. Caps have been upgraded and bypassed.

 

EF5modTesting001-S.jpg

post #2 of 12

holyyyy craps mike, i must say u got balls BALLS! to throw $1600 worth of diy upgrades at a $400 amp is something i'd consider bordering on the reckless or ... brilliant! glad its turned out so well for u.

 

bit of nosy parker here but why did u pick the EF5 to mod? was it because the topology was good that it deserved the love or cos K works recommended it? either way your mod EF5 sounds like a showcase for what good parts & great power supply/reg can do for a mediocre-average amp.

 

ps:if u dont mind, may i ask whats the range of variable resistance the box provides & would u know the precise Z u found best with the K701/2? thxs


Edited by scottiebabie - 6/13/11 at 4:49pm
post #3 of 12
Thread Starter 

Yeah, it's nuts to throw $1600 at a $400 amp, but here's the deal. I own many K Works products (power conditioning, cables, a DAC, isolation feet) and they are all designed and built by Igor. A big part of his business is custom modifications, and I talked to many members of the New Jersey Audio Society who can testify to his skill. Igor said that he hasn't heard every headphone amp out there, but he did hear this one and he said that the basic design of it seemed extremely favorable to a dimension of music that I love--DYNAMICS. I couldn't know for sure how it would work out, but it seemed like a good risk to take. And I love it.

 

As a side benefit, I probably won't ever need to change the 12AU7. My other tube amps don't have that advantage. The EF5 runs the 12AU7 at the lowest voltage I've ever heard of, and this kind of tube will last 20 years or more under those conditions. I picked up an RCA Clear Top 12AU7, recommended by the NJAS guys, for $8 on ebay. The seller underpriced them but probably didn't realize it.

 

EDIT: quick addition. The stock EF5 is not mediocre--it has good dynamics. It just has some rough edges. Don't let the $400 price fool you--it's made in China so it's relatively inexpensive with respect to the parts quality, and even stock it has some sophisticated power supply wizardry.

 


Edited by mike1127 - 6/13/11 at 9:12pm
post #4 of 12
Thread Starter 

The box goes from 0 to 120 ohms, although it's calibrated to sound best in the range 80 to 120. If I stick with the K601 I'm going to have to change the parts to get a working range of 0 to 30 ohms or so.

 

Regarding series resistance and the K701/2, I haven't done enough experimentation to be sure about that. But the K701 sounds pretty good straight out of the main jack, i.e. no resistance, so it might only degrade things to add more parts in the way.

 

post #5 of 12

didnt mean to diss the EF5 though i did have an albeit brief audition with both the hifiman HE6 & HE5LE & its was hohum at best. put it this way - my $50 vintage Sansui SS amp kicked EF5 butt with both orthos. however i didnt get a chance to listen to it with any other headphones.

 

i did recently get my hands on a set of K702s & its sounding really nice with either of my main headphone amps - vintage Sansui AU517 & Pioneer SA7500 integrateds. the Sansui gives the k702s a fuller more authoratitive bass with lusher mids while the Pioneer's more airy & extended up top. both make the K702 sound great esp with 2-4dB of bass boost - as quick & detailed as the orthos with similar bass texture & only lacking in ultimate bass body & extension.

 

only reason im asking bout output Z is cos both my vintage amps have their headout off the main amp with a coupla 220ohm resistor in series. just wondering if u are running your akg's at a similar Z out too. your mod'd super EF5 mite not be the best value buy but im glad its turned out to be a great sonic choice.

post #6 of 12
Thread Starter 

Think of the EF5 as more like a "part" than a base for a mod. K Works (Igor) has developed many tricks that can be applied in general situations. For instance, capacitor bypass combinations. RFI protection. A host of power supply upgrade ideas. When I pay Igor, I'm basically saying, "You're the one that knows what's best and you're the one with the technical skills to do right, so go for it."

 

His products have a recognizable "sonic signature"- that great K Works dynamics, extension, etc. So when I asked him to mod the EF5, I was basically saying, "Make it sound like a K Works product." $1600 for parts and major labor is what's necessary to do that. He works with a variety of circuit types, and seems to feel that most all topologies have merit if they are implemented well.

 

Is it a mystery how Igor knew ahead of time that the EF5 could reach such a high level, that it had this potential? I'm sure that Igor knew enough about that kind of circuit topology and the stock power supply design to know what could be done with it.

 

 

post #7 of 12

It's always enthralling to read about someone obtaining exactly what they want out of an audio component. Sometimes the journey is such a significant part of the overall experience. 

 

Congratulations!

 

Jack

post #8 of 12

Do you like this better than your Sonett?

post #9 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by sphinxvc View Post

Do you like this better than your Sonett?



+x1 - great question. for that matter hows the super EF5 drive the K1000 vs the audionote tubie?

post #10 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by sphinxvc View Post

Do you like this better than your Sonett?


Good question =) I wonder how this would compare to $2k+ amps.
Edited by brasewel - 6/14/11 at 4:56pm
post #11 of 12

Gosh... a believer of good components, does it really make lots of difference

post #12 of 12
Thread Starter 

I like the _modded_ EF5 better than any pure tube amp I've heard, including the Sonett and Audio Note P2 SE (by the way, the P2 SE is a single-ended pentode amp, so it shares single-endedness with the Sonett). Igor can do the same kinds of mods with other amps. I could have gotten him to mod the Sonett or P2 SE instead, but he already had experience with the EF5.

 

EDIT: the other reason I had him mod a hybrid amp rather than a pure tube amp is that as long as I can't afford silver output transformers, I feared that I would always be unhappy with the quality of transformers in a tube amp.


Edited by mike1127 - 6/14/11 at 9:25pm
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Headphone Amps (full-size)
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphone Amps (full-size) › Hifiman EF5 -- modded by K Works