Sennheiser HD25-1 or Ultrasone HFI 580 (*edited May 19 added Sony ZX700 out of curiosity)

I didn't hear HFI-580, but did own HFI-680 (less bass).

I can't imagine that for rock orientated music, 580 could even come close to HD-25.

If the clampage doesn't bother you, I'd definitely go with HD-25. And if you're up to it, even a Fiio 'L3 lod cable' with 'E5' brings noticable improvement to your sound, using your HD-25 with ipod stuff

Quote:

Originally Posted by Proglover 

I didn't hear HFI-580, but did own HFI-680 (less bass).

 

I can't imagine that for rock orientated music, 580 could even come close to HD-25.

I haven't heard the HD-25, but also doubt that the 580 would be what you were looking for. Not that I don't listen to rock (among many other things) on my 580s, but it doesn't seem like the sort of sound that people would generally say is what you want with rock. They certainly don't sound like I expect Grados would, but I've never heard any to know for sure. The 580s are somewhat flat, with some bump on the low and high ends. I wouldn't call the bass strong, but it's fairly tight and mixes well with the rest (IMO). Mids are a little distant for me (slightly), since the other bump is in the highs (which are well-represented though some seem to complain about the highs being too bright or harsh, though I haven't personally noticed anything like that).

I'd say if you've auditioned the HD-25s and are really happy with those, and don't have a way of auditioning a 580, just go for the HD-25s. You already know for sure they work and seem to like them, and the 580s are more of a question mark on whether you'd like them as much, so it would seem a safe bet that the HD-25 is the right choice.

I've heard the 580, 780 and HD25-1 and I have to agree with Proglover on rock music and the 580/780. IMO they were much better suited towards electronic music while the HD25s did better with rock if my memory serves correctly. The 580s are very agressive though with a big treble and bass but lack the midrange presence of Grados. Still no two ears are alike so it wouldn't surprise me if someone felt differently. Is there any possibility of auditioning any of your choices?

Quote:

Originally Posted by xallarap 

All right thanks for the replies. I saw some recommendations here that HFI-580 and 780 would be good choices for rock.I was just reading stuff here that the HFI-580 and 780 and our local audiophile site that it was very Grado-like for a closed headphone.  It was described as headphone aggressive sound signature, bright and quite bassy(I am a semi-basshead I think). I was considering the HFI-580 because of this(Grado-like) and it's cheaper than the HFI-780.When I tried the sr80i, HF2, and RS1 plus the MS1i on our local meets, I really loved the way they presented the songs on my player, very energetic, music almost on my face. However, although I like them very much, owning them is not practical for me as listen to music mostly at work and when I'm commuting.

 

And @idale, you're probably right on sticking with HD25. I was just looking for alternatives as the price is quite steep. It's not locally available here in my country and I would probably source it internationally. Doing so will put it around the $250 range. I am just hesitant to shell out $250 in an instant as I have other stuff to pay for. Maybe you can recommend other headphones. :)

The 580s are somewhat bright and somewhat bassy ("U response" I guess is what some people call it), and is indeed forward (I hesitate to specifically use the word "aggressive"). I don't feel like the 580 is a basshead 'phone, but the bass is definitely present (moreso than in the 780, so they say). I'm what I'd call a "bassophile", but what I love about bass is quality: I want there to be some impact but remain fairly tight and controlled and not drown out everything else. "Everything in moderation" and all that. Some people are all about the bass with less regard to the other frequencies, which would point to other headphones. If the mids were a little stronger the 580 would probably be a contender, but as they're a little distant, the more rock-like songs I have don't seem as "engaging" as I feel they could be. I don't personally care as it'd be difficult if not impossible to find something that's "ideal" for all the various music I listen to, so I'm fine with being "good" for everything.  Not to mention how it's hard to say when your source audio is what's deficient and not completely your headphones (or amp or DAC or whatever).

Unfortunately I'm new to the headphone world (generally have had to put up with what I could find in behind-the-neck portables on the laptop at home due to spousal restrictions, but needed a pair for work and wanted them to be actually good since I'll be listening to them much of the day) and there's apparently no real headphone shops in the area to audition at, so my experience is extremely limited (*cough*HFI-580 only*cough*) and my research was in a limited sector.

Here's one sample thread of someone asking about a closed-back Grado equivalent: http://www.head-fi.org/forum/thread/463720/blasphemy-looking-for-closed-phones-with-a-grado-sound . Seems from this and other threads like you can't get something with quite the same response feel, but this thread has various suggestions and the OP's got a good post on the second page where he gives his thoughts on other headphones he tried and how he liked them.

Ultrasone HFI's like Grado's? Absolutely no way

There are lots of people posting here at head-fi:)

No, Ultrasone's are not like Grado's

Just spend some more time doing searches like 'best rock headphones' 'portables rock' 'portables like Grado' (you will find that HD-25 shows up often then and practically never Ultrasones)

Good luck:)

(don't get me wrong, I'm not against Ultrasone HFI models, it's just not that close to Grado's sound)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Proglover 

There are lots of people posting here at head-fi:)

 

No, Ultrasone's are not like Grado's

True, they have different sound signatures. I like more ultrasones for bassy stuff.

Audition the ultrasone's and keep us posted!! 

As an owner of both the HD25 and a Grado, let me reassure you that the Sennheisers do rock and metal even better. There, I said it. :D Don't even think, pull the trigger on some HD25s and you're set for life. If the price is a problem, get them used.