While trying to decide on IEMs I notice that some that cost similar can have varying specifications, so my question is what's more important in deciding what IEM you want? For example: I was looking at these Brainwavz M3s and Head-Direct RE0s which similar cost , however the brainwavz have a 10.7mm driver, a sensitivity of 115db, frequency from 20 to 20kHz vs the RE0 with a 9mm driver, 100dB sensitivity, and 15 to 22kHz. So based on this which is better and why or are these things trivial?
Featured Stories
Topics Discussed
- itemBrainwavz M3
- itemHEAD DIRECT RE0 In Ear Headphones
- categoryIn Ear
Related Forum Threads
- BRAINWAVZ: M3 B2 or even M4 ? Last post on 9/21/11 at 5:01am in Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors
- is there a reason why i should try an amp? Last post on 9/19/11 at 1:33pm in Portable Headphone Amps
- So what IEM's will sound something like ATH-AD900's ? Last post on 8/14/11 at 10:24pm in Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors
- ATH-M50 achieved, time for good IEM's Last post on 8/8/11 at 11:47am in Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors
- ATH-M50 achieved, time for good IEM's Last post on 8/8/11 at 6:29am in Headphones (full-size)
Related Articles
-
Top Tier Universal Iem Comparison Chart And Information
Edited on 5/7/10
- Basic Guide To In Ear Canalphones
Edited on 3/22/12Related Head Gear
Recent Reviews
-
Introduction The ASG-2 is Aurisonics' second (official) foray into the world of iems. The guys over at Aurisonics cater primarily to the music professional crowd, and their products are...
-
My opinions Sound The sound produced by the HD558 is rich, a bit light, and isn't bloated with bass which is a good thing. It has a crisp treble and punchy bass, very great...
-
Introduction In the past 2 years VentureCraft has been successfully creating amps and DAC/Amp packaged components with their GD-03, Go-DAP 4.0 for iPhone 4(s), and Go-DAP X for their...
-
A friend of mine needed a new headphone, which was cheap, closed and good sounding. I said to him, dream on friend it will be very tough to find a headphone with those criteria. But then after...
-
Along with the summary below, I have posted a Youtube video review of the K550. If you like the video, check out my channel for more reviews :) Summary BUILD The AKG K550...
- Basic Guide To In Ear Canalphones
IEM driver vs sensitivity vs frequency
Gear mentioned in this thread:
- ClieOS
- Trader Feedback: +3
- IEM Reviewer Extraordinaire
-
- online
- 12,455 Posts. Joined 5/2004
- Location: Middle of nowhere, Johor, Malaysia.
- Select All Posts By This User
Spec are mostly trivial (while frequently misleading) and should never be relied on for judging sound quality. Read review instead, a lot of them in that matter..
Welcome to Head-fi, and sorry about your wallet.
Mmm, I learnt the hard way, many years ago, that specs are mostly useless.
Let's start by frequency range. First of all, you don't know if the frequency response is flat or not, you just get two numbers. You may think that those numbers indicate the lower and higher frequency, respectively, that the phone can reproduce. This is wrong. You don't know how these numbers were measured, and there are many ways. For example, the numbers may indicate the frequencies at which the emitted sound pressure halves. Or they may indicate the point at which the sound pressure is below the usual hearing floor. Or they may be just invented.
Without knowing the exact procedure the manufacturer followed to get those numbers, they're meaningless. The procedure should be standard so the numbers gave some meaning. But even in that case, they won't tell you anything about the sound signature. What if a phone can reproduce from 8Hz to 26kHz? It may have a "hole" in the middle and crappy voice reproduction. And I don't know about you, but I cannot hear above 18kHz if I remember correctly, so a phone with an upper limit of 26kHz won't be "better" than one with just 20k to my ears.
But again: the numbers doesn't describe the sound signature so... Impossible to compare properly a pair of phones by that number.
Another number is the sensitivity. It should be measured according to a set of standards, but you cannot be sure, so we go back to the first problem: unless you know how it was measured, it is useless. Usually, it is measured as the sound pressure level produced when you apply 1mW of power to the phones, using some predefined waveform. Please note, that's milliwatts (power), not millivolts (voltage).
So, sensitivity only gives you an approximate idea of how loud are the phones. But since manufacturers may measure this differently, you can have a phone with a sensitivity of 100dB/mW which sounds louder than another with 110dB/mW. And the manufacturer may tend to stretch the specifications and procedures so their phone gets a high number. You know, people tend to thing that the bigger, the better.
Sensitivity, again, doesn't tell you anything about sound signature, so you may buy a phone with a big sensitivity (let's say you like loud phones) and a signature you hate.
Last, another common value is THD. Total Harmonic Distortion. Again, if the procedure was standard and could be enforced, then this number may have some interest, as it would tell you how prone the phone is to distortion. Well, not exactly, but more or less it would be that.
Anyway, THD doesn't tell much about sound. The THD usually is measured applying a known waveform to the phones, at some predefined power, and then the phone response is measured, and the produced waveform compared to the original. Then, you get a percentage, indicating how the original and produced waveforms compare.
THD is meaningless, too, unless the manufacturer admits it's very high, around 1%. The manufacturer won't do that, so... I don't think there are phones with a THD greater than 0.5%, as they would sound like crap due to distortion. Don't worry about that number, either, a phone with a THD of 0.05% (not unusual) won't sound worse than another with THD of 0,01%.
Summing up, I'm with ClieOS. The only way of knowing what are you buying and if it is better than another model is reading reviews. And still, this is not enough, as reviews are written by people with particular preferences in sound (the best case) or even bias (the worst case. I cannot tell, honestly, I'm bias free). Reading many reviews may give you a general idea of the sound signature, and that may be the base to decide if you will like the phones or not. But deciding about quality only with reviews is difficult, so imagine doing it by looking at some numbers...
- IEM driver vs sensitivity vs frequency
Recent Discussions
- › The JVC HA-S500.. Appreciation, fan thread. 10 seconds ago
- › Themed Monthly Avatar Committee (TMAC) discussion thread 34 seconds ago
- › New Abyss planar magnetic headphone 37 seconds ago
- › O2 AMP + ODAC 2 minutes ago
- › DX50 a new smaller DAP coming from iBasso. . .Specifications page... 3 minutes ago
- › What book are you reading right now? 4 minutes ago
- › The Astell & Kern AK120 5 minutes ago
- › Head-Direct / HIFIMAN Customer Service TEAM 5 minutes ago
- › 「Official」Asian Anime, Manga, and Music Lounge 5 minutes ago
- › philips fidelio x1 vs hifiman he-400 (stronger natural midrange?) 6 minutes ago
Recent Reviews
- › Aurisonics ASG-2 by eke2k6
- › Sennheiser HD-558 by Tr1ckster
- › Go-Dap DD Socket1 (DD/DA Converter) for iPhone & iPod... by AnakChan
- › Philips SHL5905BK/28 CitiScape Uptown by Marleybob217
- › AKG K 550 by a_recording
- › HiFiMAN RE-400 by a_recording
- › Sony XBA-40/N Gold | Quad Balanced Armature In-Ear Headphones... by a_recording
- › Sony XBA-4SL by a_recording
- › Sony MDR-MA900 Over the Head Style Headphones by a_recording
- › Aune T1 by teb1013
New Articles
- › Mac OS X Music Players - alternatives to iTunes by miceblue
- › STAX SR-007 (Omega II) ... A Review After 4... by Currawong
- › List of lossless and high-res music (FLAC,... by ffivaz
- › Beware of the following scams and people... by Currawong
- › Sennheiser 449 Mod Possibly 4 8 Mod by hernan604
- › 2012 Head-Fi Holiday Gift Guide (Computer Audio) by joe
- › 2012 Head-Fi Holiday Gift Guide (Portable... by joe
- › 2012 Head-Fi Holiday Gift Guide (Desktop Audio) by joe
- › 2012 Head-Fi Holiday Gift Guide (Headphone... by joe
- › 2012 Head-Fi Holiday Gift Guide (Power Corner) by joe
About Head-Fi.org | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Head-Fi.org is powered by Huddler Tech | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map













