I think your confusing my dimensions. A 2.5" outer diameter still allows the cup to fit in the gimbal with a small amount of adjustment. I used cut off finishing nails the same size as the original pins to keep my chambers attached the to gimbals, others have glued their chambers to the gimbals, however then there is no adjustment possible other than bending the headband when using glue.
The 2" inner diameter cut allows the bottom portion (with the driver inside it) to be inserted into the wooden cup with a small amount of shimming (I can use less than one wrapping of tape inside to shim things tightly).
Using the 2.5" and 2" combination, you are left with a 1/2" of material, or 1/4" wall thickness which isn't too flimsy, nor is it overkill. Plus these sizes allow things to attach into the gimabls, as noted above.
The 5/4" measurement refers the the unmilled thickness of the board. A 5/4" board is in reality closer to 1.1" thick when you buy it. Wood is sold in measurements before cutting, finishing, etc that happens before you actually buy the wood. After working things down sanding, I am down to about 1" thick which is still almost 3x deeper than the original plastic outer cup.
And feel free to call me Gary. Mr. Sharkz technically would be my father.....