To answer your question, yes, I would do video editing on a new Apple MacBook Pro 17" with all of the upgrade options. This is why I need IEEE 1394B which is built into the computer. I have a SIIG IEEE 1394B Firewire 800 Mbps ExpressCard/34 to do video editing. As a matter of fact, I plan on buying Ahead Nero 10 Multimedia Suite Platinum HD this Friday along with Sid Meier's Civilization 5 for the PC.
I agree with you that spending up to $3,000.00 USD on a PC will get me much better hardware and software options. It would also not cause me a penalty to switch over to the Apple OS X operating system.
VMWare Fusion works best on high end Apple hardware such as the MacBook Pro 17" or the Mac Pro workstation. You will need a fully licensed copy to get the maximum benefits from using it. At New Jersey Institute of Technology, we have a very small Apple Macintosh computer laboratory in which we run fully licensed versions of all VMWare products including Fusion. It works perfectly, but they run Apple Mac Pro 2010 models and a few MacBook Pro 17" with the standard configurations.
$5,000.00 USD is a lot of money to spend on any computer, but I have the money and I am comfortable spending it.
I don't know when I will buy another laptop, but I am sure that it must be a laptop. I am going to be moving around a lot of different places so I truly need a mobile workstation or desktop replacement. I would be using it to code C++, Java, PHP, play Civilization 5 (this game requires modern, high end hardware and software to play smoothly), and do video editing.
I would be buying a full High Definition digital video camera with IEEE 1394B from B&H Photo Video Pro Audio store soon too. I will also buy a very high resolution digital camera for high resolution photography work as well pretty soon.
This would mean that I would need Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master Collection.
Finally, I am going to buy an Echo Digital Audio Indigo IOx ExpressCard/34 sound card. It works for both PCs and Macs. It is a high end sound card that syncs with most of the popular multi-track recording software applications on the market and I can record and mix soundtracks, music, and audio on the fly with it. It is for professional audio usage.
So, there you have it.
My understanding is such that a PC or Mac would work in either scenario.
New Jersey Institute of Technology can provide me with VMWare Fusion and Workstation 7.1.2 for free. I can get a student and teacher educational discount for Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master Collection for just $899.00 USD which is affordable.
The only thing that I would still need to buy is a SIIG IEEE 1394A and SIIG eSATA ExpressCard/34 for both my ASUS N61JV-X2 and an Apple MacBook Pro 17" so that I can have a wider selection of digital cameras and video cameras to choose from as well as being able to use my Thermaltake BlacX SATA I-II hard drive dock that has USB 2.0 and eSATA ports. This would enable me to buy very large capacity hard drives for an inexpensive price for massive storage and archival purposes.
Part of me does not want to get another PC because I want something truly different. The good thing about OS X is that the updates are cumulative and the software engineers and designers at Apple intentionally ensure that each update will work on older generation MacBooks, iMacs, and Mac Pro computers.
Microsoft usually requires a significant upgrade in hardware specifications for each successive version of their Windows and Office operating systems as the years go by. This results in the accumulation of older PC hardware for which I really do not have the means or physical storage space to maintain over the years. Furthermore, an Apple MacBook Pro is much more durable and reliable than most of their Microsoft Windows PC counterparts with the exception of semi or fully rugged computers designed for law enforcement, military, government, or field usage scenarios. Those computers cost about the same amount of money as a fully loaded Apple MacBook Pro 17", but they offer far inferior computing power.
As I have said before, I have not decided when to get one and this is merely to solicit opinions.