Well, if you didn't need closed I'd recommend the Maxell's but they are semi-open.
I'd recommend that you try the Auvio 33-279 Concert Class phones at RadioShack...
Like I said before - if you don't like them they have a 30-day no questions return policy so you can just return them and get your money back no sweat.
I think you'll be like me when you get them and say "These obviously aren't the most rugged phones ever made but holy hell what the world were those dudes on Amazon doing?"
Please don't forget to post your impressions and/or review.
It seems my other question did not post. So here it goes again.
Say I was in a library and listening to some soft rock. Would semi-open cans (like the Maxell's) at a low volume level disturb others that are studying around me? If not, what about open cans?