Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › Poll: Several Mid-Fi Offerings versus a Single Hi-Fi Offering
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Poll: Several Mid-Fi Offerings versus a Single Hi-Fi Offering

Poll Results: Would you Rather Own Several, Mid-fi "Sweet-Spot" sets of Headphones or a Single "Hi-Fi" Flagship set of Headphones?

Poll expired: Jul 27, 2010  
  • 50% (72)
    Several Mid-Fi, Sweet-Spot Products
  • 49% (70)
    A Single Hi-Fi Flagship Product
142 Total Votes  
post #1 of 128
Thread Starter 

Please respond to the poll AND offer a reason, or reasons, why you answered the way you did.  : )  Answer under the assumption that you DO have sufficient funds to be able to purchase any of the current flagship offerings (e.g. HD800. T1, ED8, etc.) and kindly limit the purview to DYNAMIC headphones.

 

Thank you!

 

Here is my rationale (shamelessly borrowed from the tail end of the "T1 vs. DT880/600, Round 1" thread):

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

As long as there exist Sennheiser, Beyerdynamic, AKG, Ultrasone, Denon, JVC, Audio-Technica, et al, there will be unique brand- and design-specific advantages to ownership within a fairly broad array of headphone products.  If one were financially able--and not all of us are--I guess the way to go would be to purchase all the available flagship offerings.

 

But for the majority of us--myself included--the "next best thing" is to buy from the mid-fi "sweet spot" of those manufacturers with whom your listening preferences click.  For me, that would include the AKG K501, Beyer DT880/600 and Denon AH-D5000.  [And possibly, if I were fallen into reckless abandon, the Ultrasone 750Pro, reserved for female vocals.]

 

That way, I can capitalize on the inimitable keynote(s) of each (e.g. the K501's cohesiveness and peerless midrange integrity; the DT880/600's detail, balance and dynamic texture; the AH-D5000's engrossing bass lines; the 750Pro's haunting upper midrange).  

 

This often requires a more selective, genre-targeted style of listening, and that the listener make concessions to comparative weaknesses while exploiting comparative strengths in the headphones of choice at the time, but I think--at least for me--this is the more satisfactory way to go. 

 

Honestly, I don't believe there ever will exist, nor ever can exist, a single, flagship, "hi-fi" product that could pull off all those respective performance pluses on par with each of the above-mentioned "mid-fi" offerings.  If that were so, then headphone listening will have become lamentably homogenized, and our universe would be slipping irreversibly into immanent maximum entropy, into a black hole of formless mediocrity.

**********************************************************************************************************


Edited by pataburd - 7/6/10 at 2:17pm

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 128

Mid Fi. I can get many different sound sigs so I can choose which can I want to listen to depending on my mood, isolation needs, and genre. Also being a college student kinda limits my spending. Though if I had the money I'd love to have a collection like Skylab.

 

I really like what I have now

 

AD2000: Gaming and trance

D2000: Bass centered music

W1000: Jazz, Classical, etc

Pro 650: Transportable

HD280: Isolation/Studying


Edited by NapalmK - 7/6/10 at 2:20pm
post #3 of 128

Hi-fi if I could ever afford one. You can only wear one pair of headphones at a time and I only use headphones for gaming/semi-portable so I don't really need an open set. I'd rather listen to speakers if I'm just chilling at home. My mid-fi Ultrasones are good enough for me and atm I can't fathom spending $1700 on UE9s.

post #4 of 128

"If less is more imagine how much more would be!" (quoted from someone else)

 

Go for many headphones, at least 2 or 3 if you can manage. Splurge and get a couple vastly different amps too.  Unlike large heavy cube-oids (speakers) there is absolutely no reason to limit yourself to 1 headphone. Variety is the spice of life, enjoy it! 

post #5 of 128

I'd say single Hi-Fi.

 

Especially after hearing the JH13. ♥

post #6 of 128
Thread Starter 

C'mon, folks, we need an n of 100 to get a credible estimate of the proportions here.  : )

 

This thread has had 70 hits, but only 9 answers so far, a 13% response rate.  I just know we can do better.


Edited by pataburd - 7/6/10 at 7:51pm
post #7 of 128
I sold a number of mid-fi headphones to pay for the HD-800. I think it was worth it. Of course, I also went and bought a few other high-end cans. And speakers, for that matter. I think I might need professional help.
post #8 of 128

I voted for several for a few reasons.

 

Variety, obviously. Some days I want a bright headphone, others I want some really nice mids, still other days I have a craving for a warm sound and at the moment, I lack that. If I have just one headphone, I'm kind of screwed if I have a craving for what it doesn't have. As far as I know, there isn't a jack of all trades, master of all high end headphone, so I'd have to settle for what I have and I'm ADD about things like that. You can only wear one pair, but that one pair can get tiresome pretty quickly if you're like me.

 

**** happens. If my O2 or such somehow breaks, I'll be stuck with some cheapos which make me not want to listen to music. I'd rather listen to a Thunderpants (This can be mid-fi right? It's a mid-fi price, about $2-300 depending on what wood I use and the price of the rest of the stuff I need if I make it myself.) Won't be as good as the real thing, but within spitting distance of it at least.) with rock while my SR325 is being fixed than use disposables for critical listening.

 

"Quiet down! I need to study!" Yeah, I'll probably have issues with that if I have only one pair of high end headphones because they'd be open (O2, LCD2, Qualia) and with 2 sisters, that's just not really sensible. I'll stick to my closed headphones for that.

 

"Dude...those cans are massive." I'm not talking about those cans you pervs! But yes, I'll need music with me at all times and I'd look utterly silly with a headphone system with me. I needs me some IEMs. JH customs probably wouldn't do for me either because they're high-end, I guess. There'll be times I'd actually like to hear things at home too.


Edited by Ishcabible - 7/6/10 at 8:04pm
post #9 of 128

I vote several mid-fi offerings.  Especially if you are just venturing into the world of Hi-Fidelity.  Once you know what you prefer you may then trade for a single ultra exotic can - or two...or three.

post #10 of 128

Several midfi, I like building up and hearing how much greater the sound gets. I can eventaully sell my mid-fi headphones and upgrade to some high-fi headphones, or just keep the mid-fi and but the high-fi.

post #11 of 128
One headphone to rule them and in the darkness bind them
post #12 of 128

Several mid-fi.

 

Since we'll never get a pair of headphones that is both open and closed, I'd rather have 1 open mid-fi and 1 closed mid-fi. This way, I have a pair for using during quite times, and a pair to listen in the comfort of my bedroom.

post #13 of 128
Quote:
Originally Posted by rhythmdevils View Post

One headphone to rule them and in the darkness bind them


LOL!

post #14 of 128

I'm a collector by nature.  I have 120 gigs of music on my portable hard drive.  I own 800 DVDs.  Mid-fi headphones allow me to exercise that collection compulsion without going completely broke.  I could sell everything I've collected in my headphone journey and buy a high-end can, say the T1.

 

That would leave me wondering what those high-end orthos sound like.   Hmm... I wonder if a Stax setup would be better...

 

I know myself, and I know what I can afford.  That's why I don't even let myself contemplate the really high end cans.

 

Also, I wonder how many people who voted one high-end can actually just OWN one high end can, or any at all...

post #15 of 128
Thread Starter 

Just 73 more responses and I can compute a confidence interval estimate for the true proportion of those who prefer several (or a single) headphone(s)!  : )

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Headphones (full-size)

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › Poll: Several Mid-Fi Offerings versus a Single Hi-Fi Offering