Head-Fi.org › Forums › Misc.-Category Forums › Music › Who Vs. Led Zeppelin
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Who Vs. Led Zeppelin - Page 3

post #31 of 138
Led Zep
post #32 of 138
Based on my naïve and limited experience I like Led Zeppelin better. I have only heard Led Zeppelin 1 while I have heard The Who Who’s next and live at Leeds. From that small sample I concur both bands are awesome in their own right and like each one immensely. I guess Zep just does it for me more.
post #33 of 138
I had to go with The Who, though I am listening to Led Zep [I] right now. Overall, I think I'll go with the Who, for some of the same reasons as Trawlerman, and Voodoochile. This was a really hard poll though.
post #34 of 138
Thread Starter 
I might start 2 other polls - best zep album and best who album because this one is gettin good feedback
post #35 of 138
I voted Zepp. They have some excellent tunes. I've not come across one yet by them which I've not found amazing. The Who have some good stuff, but I don't think I've heard enough by them to make a versus judgement. "HeartBreaker/Living Loving Maid" is a great song, probably one of my favs. Great guitar solo that varies in various versions. I have about 4 versions of the song, all are great, but this one particular live version is imo the way it's supposed to be. Led Zeppelin really sounds great live.
post #36 of 138
Really tough decision. I'd have to say, for me, the Who win by a (Pete Townsend's) nose.
post #37 of 138
Thats a tough call, but I slightly favor Zeppelin.
post #38 of 138
You guys are just joking right?????? (I hope that is the case)

Zep completely blows away Who............even if Zep only released 1st album they would still rule Who............what has Who done than can even begin to compare to song like "dazed and confused", this a another league entirely
post #39 of 138
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally posted by DarkAngel
Zep completely blows away Who
Wheres the evidence eh? I think its a fair match.
post #40 of 138
I voted earlier [LZ] and have been watching the results. Its right back at 50/50 again!

Maybe this thread just needs to be closed right now and considered a tie.
post #41 of 138
Thread Starter 
I'm going for The Who (although I love Zep)
post #42 of 138
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeM
I voted earlier [LZ] and have been watching the results. Its right back at 50/50 again!

Maybe this thread just needs to be closed right now and considered a tie.
Could this be the closest poll ever?
post #43 of 138
Didn't someone on another thread say that once a poll starts going one way, it never swings around? Oh, well, so much for his argument.

Hey, people, as you post, mention how the poll is doing.

Right now, it's 28 to 28 -- even tie. I've seen it swing both ways, though, up until this point.
post #44 of 138
DarkAngel is correct. Zep 1 >> entire Who output, leaving Zeps 2 to ITTOD to completely overbalance things.

Needless to say I voted Zep.
post #45 of 138
Compared to Zep, the Who is rather wussified--they didn't have much understanding of blues.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Music
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Misc.-Category Forums › Music › Who Vs. Led Zeppelin