Head-Fi.org › Forums › Misc.-Category Forums › Members' Lounge (General Discussion) › Opinion poll on major education/life decision
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Opinion poll on major education/life decision

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
I am completely stuck on a major decision and thought I'd reach out to the community for some feedback. In addition to your opinion on what I should do, it would be wonderful to hear from community members who have made similar decisions and how it has worked out.

I have been blessed to gain acceptance into two good MBA programs: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and the University of South Carolina. The Illinois program is a traditional 2-year program with a good track record of placing people into jobs in Chicago (my preferred destination after school). The South Carolina program is unique in that it has a 3rd year built in for language immersion and internship in a foreign country (Japan would be my choice). I am currently interested in studying marketing, in particular consumer decision and the influence of culture on those decisions. Product development is also a strong interest of mine. Both schools would be good for this course of study, but tackle it from different directions.

I have been in limbo/purgatory for the last two years as just about every major decision I have made in the last 10 years turned out against me. I am divorced, broke, and unemployed. Needless to say, I view the opportunity to go back to school as a godsend and just about every part of my life is now tied to this decision. Part of me wants the incredible experience of living abroad for a year. Experiencing a foreign culture up close, learning an incredibly difficult language, and being truly alone and independent for a year would be a life changing experience. However, I dislike the South quite a bit (no offense to any fine Southerners here), and would most likely need to spend several years in the South after school as 85% of graduates from USC are placed there (not ideal). Not only that, I will be 35 by the end of the program, and living anywhere I don't see myself settling down in for a couple years makes me anxious, as I do want a family of my own and feel like I can't really pursue that until I am settled somewhere. I have a very strong desire to get where I am going as soon as I can so I can start building my life again.

That being said, I tend to be a person who regrets decisions, and passing up the opportunity to do something that not only most people are too afraid to do, but rarely get the opportunity if they are willing might haunt me for the rest of my life. I fear that in my hurry to get back to a comfortable life that I might be passing up the opportunity to truly distinguish my experience from those around me. Then again, spending an extra year out of the work force at a school that has a slightly lower reputation and ability to help graduates get the top jobs, could end up impacting my career for the next 30 years.

So U of Illinois presents me with a safer, shorter path (in theory at least) to a good career in a great city where I can see myself settling down. It will by no means be a dull experience (I won't let it be), but it definitely involves less risk. USC presents me with a more immediately fascinating experience, but with far more risk and possible delays getting to a similarly comfortable level. With my recent struggles in life, I am afraid that my tolerance for risk and delay are not what they used to be. That said, I do see great value in breaking free of my inhibitions.

I think both would be smart, reasonable choices. Both, in my mind, have equal amounts of positives and negatives. Each would force me to make compromises that I really don't want to make. I am definitely leaning one direction right now, but I vascillate daily.

I think getting other opinions and stories might help me make a better decision, so have at it! Should I be a Fighting Illini or a Gamecock? And don't worry, this is more for curiosity's sake. Your opinions will not be factored heavily into my decision
post #2 of 16
Well Fraggler, i've been in chicago and it's a great city, plenty of life and energy. Japan is pretty much the same depending on which city you decide to reside in. Even though there is a "safer" route, it seems USC involves more studies, on top of that you're going out of the country, getting you out of your comfort zone, it will really test your abilities and give you more experience which will help you later as you progress into your career. Since you're a marketing major i think the more experience the better. I'm actually in the somewhat of the same situation. I've been accepted to med school, but i'm really debating on if i should stay on my current college at the University of Iowa. They have a great medical program and is guaranteed job positions in the future. Or i can go all the way to Texas and have the opportunity t go overseas when i'm ready for my residency. I'm really leaning towards texas right now based on what i said, it's really up to you, if you're confident you'll excel in your studies then all the power to you.
post #3 of 16
it is great that you have been given a choice but it is just that YOUR choice. No one can or should make it for you. You have to deside what your comfort level is and the pro's an cons of each decision. What I would suggest is to get a piece of paper and on 1 side write the pros and cons of each to help you make the choice. Everybody will make different choices then the next person for reasons of their own and you need to do the same.

If you would like some input I would suggest you not ask where you should go but if anyone has pros and cons for each and why so you can add some information to help you decide not to have someone decide for you, which is easily done but not in a malicious way just giving you how they would choose.

Good luck and good job for getting a great opportunity.
post #4 of 16
Not sure how Japan is the same wherever you go; I mean, nothing is as diverse as China, but Japan is very unique, harbours at least 3 completely different people groups, maybe more (not composed of immigrants), countless dialects, industries, foods - it ain't the same. I would suggest moving away, really away if you want to take advantage of learning/experiencing and building on a unique career. Study in the school which takes you out of what to you has become insular surroundings.

Good luck.
post #5 of 16
It's whichever you like, I imagine U of I would be the bigger name degree, but I know too many Illini grads that don't have the best of things to say about the school. Not to say lots of people don't love it, but the handful of my friends that went off there didn't think too highly of it.

The end result is all that matters though, and a U of I MBA would be quite a nice degree to have.
post #6 of 16
If you take SC, it shows you are willing to take a challenge and proof is success in your results. I'd rather have the person willing to learn outside their comfort zone.
post #7 of 16
The way I look at it you will be 35 regardless if you complete it or not. I would rather be 35 with a Masters in Business than 35 without it. Sacrifice now and reap the reward when you are 35. Where you go after that has so many variables that you will know what the right decision is when you get there. It is all about the journey. I have lived in Japan and it is a wonderful place to be but have also lived in Germany and it has a really different culture for sure. Loved both. Hell you may get an offer in the US that you just can't refuse. Like the Nike commercial, "JUST DO IT".
post #8 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by FraGGleR View Post
That being said, I tend to be a person who regrets decisions, and passing up the opportunity to do something that not only most people are too afraid to do, but rarely get the opportunity if they are willing might haunt me for the rest of my life. I fear that in my hurry to get back to a comfortable life that I might be passing up the opportunity to truly distinguish my experience from those around me. Then again, spending an extra year out of the work force at a school that has a slightly lower reputation and ability to help graduates get the top jobs, could end up impacting my career for the next 30 years.

So U of Illinois presents me with a safer, shorter path (in theory at least) to a good career in a great city where I can see myself settling down. It will by no means be a dull experience (I won't let it be), but it definitely involves less risk. USC presents me with a more immediately fascinating experience, but with far more risk and possible delays getting to a similarly comfortable level. With my recent struggles in life, I am afraid that my tolerance for risk and delay are not what they used to be. That said, I do see great value in breaking free of my inhibitions.
Well for starters you are afterall fortunate enough to make a choice since you have one.

And since you are saying that our answers will not weigh much in your decision then if I would be you I think I would take the two year programme. As you say it is the most "safe" path to take and you mention recent struggles and to me it might look like in the way you write in this post that there might be a self-fulfilling prophecy in the making if you decide to take the 3 year programme (just my opinion since you ask for it).

Fair enough that you mention that the 3 year programme will make you study abroad for a year, but as the 2 year programme will hopefully let you spend one year less in your course then logically I would personally think of that as one year "saved" and in a sense you could always down the line "use" that year for something similar in the future when you would be feeling different towards yourself then you might do today.
post #9 of 16
well from what i read youd find south carolina more exciting in every way but if you wouldnt be happy living there then dont go.

if youd hate living there it will affect everything you do there.
post #10 of 16
I would say to take the U Illinois program and get your degree as fast as you can. After that search and see if you can get on with a company that offers opportunities to work in Japan. Really, it would probably be better to get there out of school and with work rather than still being in school.
post #11 of 16
Go with the University of Illinois so you can work within two years in the Chicago area.
post #12 of 16
I'd go with the South Carolina program. Spending a year abroad would be valuable. Also, I don't think the economy will bottom out until the end of 2012 or so. That's when the rest of the mortgage mess will finally reset. If you can stay off the market for an extra year, you might be able to pick up a job when things are looking better.
post #13 of 16
I am not going to answer the poll but I believe you should always be trying to get back into the workforce as quickly as possible. I look back many many years ago and I had a choice to either attend a two year technology program or a four year engineering problem. I decided on the two year program and I have to say that my career has far surpassed those of my friends at the time who took the 4 year path.

The important thing is to listen to your heart, make a choice and don't look back. Don't overthink this.
post #14 of 16
as a former academic, I'd like to mention the class-consciousness of academia-- the better the university, the more clout your degree will have. i don;t know which of the two programs is more prestigious, but whichever one is, that will help you on your resume, as more an more folks have MBA's, the one's from more highly regarded institutions will open more doors for you.

just my 2 cents!
post #15 of 16
Thread Starter 
Thank you all for your opinions. All of you echo thoughts that I have had and they are all valid, which leads to the dilemma. I believe I have made my decision, although I won't make it official until I get some documentation in. In the end, after weighing pluses and minuses came to a draw, I am going with my gut. I don't know if my instinct is going to be right, but I definitely know I have gone against my gut several times before and it turned out poorly for me every single time. As amazing an experience I know South Carolina would be, something just feels right about the opportunity at Illinois. I am very excited and thankful for my opportunity and it is now up to me to make the best of it.

PS Canjam being in Chicago this year has nothing to do with the decision.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Misc.-Category Forums › Members' Lounge (General Discussion) › Opinion poll on major education/life decision