Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors › Sennheiser IE8 versus Ultimate Ears TripleFi 10
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Sennheiser IE8 versus Ultimate Ears TripleFi 10

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
The Sennheiser IE8 or the Ultimate Ears TripleFi 10? You decide:

Here's a quick review from my experience owning these IEMs.
Firstly I would like to note that I have owned the IE8 for about a year now, and the TF10 for only a day.

Fit/Comfort
I prefer using the Comply Foam Tip for both Earphones as they provide a snug fit; the silicone tips just pop up seconds after I put them on,

The IE8s' shape fit the ear more smoothly: if using the silicone ear tips they sit flat on the ear, if using the Comply Foam tips, they stick out about 1/4cm.
The TF10s' shape is a joke, it sticks out making it easy to fall off with a simple nudge, but this is only my opinion.

Overall, they both are comfortable when put on right.

Sound
(sorry not really good at describing highs meds lows, anyone wanna help, please post and I'll update my opinions, )
The IE8s have been burned in for quite a bit now, I have used it nearly everyday for ~4+ hours per day since the day I got it(about a year ago), I have also burned it in for a couple hours.
The IE8s have crisp and clear vocals/treble; the bass is deep and can get loud, and brings many sound unheard from other audio devices.

The TF10s have a muddier sound in vocals/treble, but the bass is a bit clearer and louder than the IE8s(Should be the opposite? )

Appearance
The IE8s have a formal, black/silver logo, nothing too special, while the TF10s have a flashy style, (ex. when you put it on, they look like advertisements on both sides of your ears, )

Build/Quality
I've read around that the IE8s' tips may fall off(can be superglued back in w/o voiding the warranty) while taking off the Comply Foam Tips, but this has never occurred to me.
For the TF10s, I recall reading somewhere about problems about the wires, but nothing has been a issue with it, yet..
The TF10s sport gold plated tips and also stiffer wiring at the top, for better fit(IE8s also do, they are detachable).
They both have detachable wiring, the IE8s have a thin and more flexible wire while the TF10s have a thick and a bit stiff wiring.

Packaging
The IE8s have a nicer packaging and appearance: a metal packaging with a flap that opens and reveals the Earphones and some of the ear tips.
They also use the earphone case as part of the packaging.
The TF10s packaging isn't as great as the IE8s', it's a simple card-stock box, with a plastic window in the front displaying the earphones and on the back, separate windows for each ear tip set, and a misalignedview of the metal case.
But the packaging shouldn't be considered when deciding between the two..

Case
The IE8 case is made of plastic with metal in the top and bottom. It is designed like a "cabinet" with a magnet in the back holding the "drawer" in. The case is organized and has slots for a dehumidifier/silica gel(on the back), 2 sets of extra ear tips, tool(ear wax cleaner/bass adjuster), and separate L/R spots for each earpiece with a "tunnel" that leads to a spot to coil the wire around, pretty neat.
The TF10 is just a basic metal case lined with rubber and fabric, I use the case for the earphones and sound attenuator

Accessories
The IE8 comes with ear "hooks" for a "better" fit, and a wide variety of different ear tips and sizes(10 total?).
The TF10 comes with 6 sets of different ear tips(2 pairs of Comply Foam Tips), extension cable, 1/4" adapter, and sound attenuator.

There you have it!!
Both earphones have their pros and cons.
I'll update this with pictures later on.

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 21
so do you like the ie8s better?
post #3 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by myk7000 View Post
so do you like the ie8s better?
Somewhat,
post #4 of 21
I have both as well thanks to Logitechs $99 TF10 sale. I have owned the IE8s almost a year and a half and mine are burned in as well.

I have alot of listening to do but here is a mini review. I really just got them and have to get used to its sound signature more to see in the end which I prefer. So far the treble on the TF10 has more clarity to it, but the IE8 has more bass and wider soundstage.

Although sound quality is most important to me in the end, for IEMS comfort is a close second. I am surprised I can wear the TF10 comfortably considering how cumbersome they are in size and shape. It feels natural for me to wear the TF10 with the cable over my ears while the IE8 I wear cable down (I just do not like them cable up with or without the ear hooks). The IE8 also has a much better cable to me, very strong yet maleable while TF10 are extremely stiff. The supplied comply tips are great with the TF10, but much like the IE8, I have settled on using them with Sony Hybrid tips. The IE8 are vastly more comfortable to wear overall.
post #5 of 21
I'm surprised to see that the OP describes the TF10's treble as "muddier" than the IE8's.
post #6 of 21
Triple.fi has very clear and sharp treble - the OP just has a bad fit I guess. IE8 treble is a little grainy and harsh by comparison.
post #7 of 21
I can't even use the comply foams with mine, I find that it's too hard for me too keep the foam from closing off one of the holes and nerfing the sound. Sometimes it would muffle the treble, sometimes the mids. I can get a decent/good seal with the medium silicones but i'm still not used to how they feel compared to the gel tips on my klipsch custom 3's.
post #8 of 21
Harsh isn't a word that I would use to describe the IE8's treble compared to the TF10. I think it presents more softly but its extension seems boundless.
post #9 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by crapback View Post
I can't even use the comply foams with mine, I find that it's too hard for me too keep the foam from closing off one of the holes and nerfing the sound. Sometimes it would muffle the treble, sometimes the mids. I can get a decent/good seal with the medium silicones but i'm still not used to how they feel compared to the gel tips on my klipsch custom 3's.
Ya the Klipsch gels are the best IEM tips I have ever used. It is too bad they use a non standard thin stem tip otherwise I'd use em on all my IEMs. It's too bad I misplaced my Klipsch X10s. They were great.
post #10 of 21
I did an A-B on both the IE8 and TF10' today. If I have to put 1 word each to describe how they sound:

IE8 - airy
TF10 - tight

I can see the mid-bass hump discussed around here on the TF10. I can Izotope the TF10 easier and achieve very good result.

Here's how I am going to use them:

For desktop listening - TF10 with Izotope and Studio Sound FX

For on the road with D10/H140 - IE8
post #11 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by TopQuark View Post
I did an A-B on both the IE8 and TF10' today. If I have to put 1 word each to describe how they sound:

IE8 - airy
TF10 - tight

I can see the mid-bass hump discussed around here on the TF10. I can Izotope the TF10 easier and achieve very good result.

Here's how I am going to use them:

For desktop listening - TF10 with Izotope and Studio Sound FX

For on the road with D10/H140 - IE8
I hear more mid bass in the IE8 than I do with the TF10.
post #12 of 21
Well, I've been listening to the triple.fis only for the past two days. Just now I noticed that one channel had become quieter than the other side so I'm gonna try and get that resolved next week.

But since one channel became quiet, I decided to bring out the IE8s. And I think I can definitely say I prefer the IE8s now. I can appreciate the more balanced sound of the TF10s, but the IE8s just sound more natural, smooth and are more pleasing to my ears. I was noticing that vocals sound a bit weird on the TF10s, but maybe it's just 'cause I'm more used to the IE8 presentation. And of course, comfort is better on the IE8s. The cable on the TF10 is sucky too, while the IE8's is just amazing.

Simply put, the IE8s put a smile on my face everytime I listen, even after all these months I've had them.
I think I'll be selling the triple.fis sometime soon. I was strongly considering turning them into customs, but I believe I would still listen to my IE8s more in the end, so no point wasting my money. I'll recoup my cash.
post #13 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by iponderous View Post
I'm surprised to see that the OP describes the TF10's treble as "muddier" than the IE8's.
i can see why, i always felt the treble on the tf10 never lived up to the hype back when i was using just out of the hp out on my 5G ipod. then i got a line out and icon mobile and BOOM!!! the treble got crazy sharp and crisp
post #14 of 21
^ Well it sounded lively to me from the get-go straight from my ipod touch, so no, I really don't understand the OP's reaction at all.
post #15 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by HONEYBOY View Post
I hear more mid bass in the IE8 than I do with the TF10.
x2 again.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors › Sennheiser IE8 versus Ultimate Ears TripleFi 10