Quote:
Originally Posted by musicmind 
The part where Page asks Edge whether he is sure about the chord in the U2 song "I will follow" was amusing too lol. In terms of getting 3 big name, instantly recognisable guitarists to ensure maximum viewer appeal across different age groups and musical tastes, I think the choice of these three guitarists was quite well done... 
|
I thought that the comment by Page that you mention was either a bit of guitarist/ego, good-natured ribbing, or it was in response to or leading to that part where The Edge discusses how he modified, I believe it was, an E Chord. (I forget whether The Edge made that comment before the comment you mention or not..). I know the point of the three guitarists that were chosen for the film is one that can be debated endlessly. I noticed that Jimmy Page was the associate producer of the film. I bet that he had some say as to who the other two guitarists would be. I had a thought that Jack White was chosen because he's kind of like the young "blues/purist" side of Jimmy Page. The Edge might have been chosen because he's the technologically experimental side of Jimmy Page. (they mentioned how Page was instrumental in the development of the distortion/fuzz box, they briefly discussed his use of the violin bow, and they demonstrated the theramin in the closing credits and in the deleted scenes...)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jubei 
Personally, felt the Edge felt out of place of a few blues based jams, but overall, all three guitarists come across nicely. Very interesting documentary.
|
I love all three of the guitarists that were featured in the film and I definitely agree that there were times when The Edge appeared somewhat uncomfortable with the other two. I have read interviews with the various members of U2 and they frequently discuss that when they began as a band they really couldn't play. I think that there may still be some deep-seated insecurity there. Of course, there can't be many guitarists that wouldn't experience some insecurity being on stage trading riffs with Jimmy Page.