Yes. Many times while under the influence - I once had a really weird reaction to the Symphony Fantastique under such circumstances. My SACD has a binaural version where they stuck a Neumann head in the balcony. It really sounds like you're there. Also, the music is a little freaky - check out the history of the piece - it's interesting. Some psychedelic rock (namely DSoTM and "Dusk at Cubist Castle" by the Olivia Tremor Control) still occasionally catch me off guard even though I've listened to both many, many times.
One that still catches me is "Waltz for Debby" by Bill Evans. It's an excellent recording and the SACD is superb. It's recorded live and catches a lot of background noise at the club. When using really sensitive gear (the HD-800, DT48, ribbons, and the Quad ESL-63) the background voices sometimes sound like they're coming from outside the room. More than once I've paused the disc to make sure no one is outside.
The Quads and ribbons have freaked me out many times, too. Sometimes, I've left them on playing the radio and came back to what really sounds like someone in the house when I open the door. If anyone is curious about freakily real vocals, try planars. They can genuinely fool you. If there was a singer and a pair of Magnepans, ribbons, electrostats, or AMTs behind a curtain, I'm not sure I could A/B the difference between them.