More sneak peek into my JH13Pro thoughts (to put into my review)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pale Rider 
After these last few posts, I got out my Westone 3s. When I first got them, I didn't hear the sibilance that some others had identified. At the time, they were replacing a pair of stolen UM2s, and my only other point of reference was my Etys. But the difference between the 13s' non-strident detail and what I would now call the W3's sizzle--that may be too strong; zing might be better--is pretty clear. I think I am going to do a little more comparison. But I do not hear any "magically smoothing out" going on with my 13s. All the detail of cymbals, snares, sticks, high violin registers and female vocals is there, but without the edge. It's the difference between making it look/feel/hear easy versus straining to get the job done. Whether the W3s are trying too hard, or are for some other reason too forward above 5-6k, I think that difference is where some of the musicality gets lost in the W3s.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lil' Knight 
Sounds like a balanced B22 + HD600s.
How about the soundstage? The best soundstage I've heard in the portable phones is from my Yuin PK1.
|
I can appreciate what you are saying about W3 vs JH13Pro. I'll break part of my silence in advance of my 3-flagship review to talk about JH13Pro vs W3. Sorry Sinocelt, you still have to wait for the review...
Switching to my W3 with UM56 custom tips, after using the JH13Pro and the IE8, I hear no "sizzle" (only slight zing) with my W3, but I can get some "zing" to it with single flange silicone tips. It's amazing what these UM56 custom tips to for the W3 sound, and they bring the W3 highs closer to sounding "magically smoothed out". And I agree, the JH13Pro need no smoothing out, as there is no edge nor anything missing.

Nevertheless, where I hear the biggest differences are in the deep bass peak of the JH13Pro (50Hz) vs the mid/upper bass peak of the W3, where the power and impact are increased with the JH13Pro without artificially coloring the sound (psychoacousticly almost felt more than heard).
The next is the somewhat smaller soundstage of the W3 - it's like the difference you hear when switching between listening to HD600 single ended vs HD600 balanced. I used to think of the W3 soundstage as large before I got several high end customs, now I consider it good but not the best. In a similar example, I also used to think of the Woo WA6 amp as having a big soundstage till I heard the same phones on the balanced WA22 and EC ZDT amps. Seems like there is always something better to replace your previous "best".
The next big difference with the JH13Pro is in the detail and transparency, especially in complex musical passages where the JH13Pro almost sound as if there is one dedicated driver per instrument with reproduction of the utmost clarity and resolution.

While in comparison to such high-end customs the W3 almost seem to blend the sounds all together.