Quote:
Originally Posted by barleyguy 
44.1K audio goes to 22K, and most well produced music has signal all the way to 22K. As far as physical instruments, the only thing that produces over 15K is cymbals (generally). Mostly what you lose over 15K is soundstage, "air", and "space". 18K is especially critical for the height/depth part of soundstage.
That said, most people over about 35 can't hear test tones over 16K. But I still believe that if those frequencies are missing, most well trained ears can hear the loss of soundstage and air.
So, IMO, frequencies up to 20K are essential for sound quality, especially when it comes to soundstage. This could be one of the reasons that full size cans with a wider frequency range sound "bigger".
|
This post might date me

, but this is a point that I agree with. Interestingly, Harmon Kardon was one of the early pioneers of the square wave mantra, emphasizing bandwidth in their pre/amp designs that were flat to well beyond 100K. (Many audio magazines still highlight amplifier performance using this metric.) The premise was that what we can't hear--especially in the upper regions--impacted the overall tonality and harmonic structure of the amplifier reproducing frequencies within our primary range of hearing. I don't want to get into the square wave revolution too much, but in the ES3X Appreciation thread, I submitted a post that described this point. Here's an excerpt from that post that supports barleyguy's premise:
"As an interesting aside, in the 70's JBL released a recording that demonstrated the impact of filtering the highest frequencies and its effect on the lower registers. Using a solo violin, they filtered the highest frequencies starting at 18K, 15K, 12K, and so on. The basic character of the violin was always apparent, but the instrument became more box-like, more basic in its fundamentals as the highest frequencies were filtered. The "air" and sense of effortlessness was lost. I could easily determine when each successive filter was applied, always preferring the unfettered and free sound of an unfiltered violin."