Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › My search for great thrash metal headphones
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

My search for great thrash metal headphones - Page 15

post #211 of 225
Wow, long time no see. I've been away from HF for a good while. Good to see you've got a Lambda, they're good phones, and amazing when you think about how old they are. Still, Quad ESL-57 and ESL-63 are older still and are still some of the best speakers ever made, so maybe it's not that surprising after all. However that T-amp isn't doing your Lambdas any favors and some of the bass lightness you refer to could easily come from that. The transformer box doesn't really have much of a voicing of its own beyond softening up the bass and rolling off the highs slightly. The rest of the voicing comes from the amp, and you want to make sure that it is a good one. Old-school soupy-sounding tube amps - like what you would probably would have been using when the Lambda was new - pair really well with it and help fill the sound out. I don't think I need to remind you just how hard-hitting and robust electrostatic bass can be, not after you heard the O2 And it's not the only one, the HE90 also has some seriously full and rich bass, if somewhat one-note.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris19 View Post
I can't say anything about the open-air Ultrasones, like the PRO 2500 or HFI-2200, because I haven't heard them. But, if anyone can confirm that they have speed and clarity in the mids, then I'd give those a shot too. They should be cheaper as well.
I spent some good quality time with the 2500 after my friend let me borrow his pair. I really noted two things about them:

1) they weren't the complete and utter rubbish that I thought most Ultrasones were at the time, and
2) they had some very glaring flaws that detracted from an otherwise interesting and potentially good presentation.

Namely, there was a peak in the lower treble that made them sound splashy and sibilant, there was a coloration in the midrange that made the mids sound plasticky and textureless though they were otherwise pretty fluid, and the bass was somewhat boomy and one-note even though it went very deep. The speed was pretty good for a dynamic, but still dynamic. The soundstage was small but imaging was very good, and dynamic range and detail were both very good for the price. Not a bad sound by any means but it was somewhat harsh and unrealistic, though also vivid and clear at the same time. I would imagine that these phones would impress on first listen with well-recorded material but would quickly start to grate and annoy because of their colorations.

The Omega 2 is calling you. You know it!

I'm getting the JH13 soon, as soon as ears heal up and I can finally get a good set of ear impressions made. I really do think that balanced armatures are going to take over as the primary high-end headphone driver technology; they have a great combination of speed and impact by definition, and they are just about the only driver technology that has seen significant advancement over the years - and there's no indication that they've peaked yet. Even my old ES2 from 4 years back had a wonderful combination of speed and impact (though more impact than speed) and the JH13 is shaping up to be special. Even the UM3x I'm messing around with now is sounding like I never thought a universal-fit canalphone could sound like 3 years ago.

So it might be something to look into I'll definitely report back when I get it.

Also, check out two Koss phones: A250 for a dynamic, and ESP950 for a 'stat. Now, I'm recommending the ESP950 based on opinions that I trust rather than personal experience but the A250 is seriously fast for a dynamic. It does a great deal of things that Ultrasones do but it is less colored and more technically capable. It does have absolutely blistering treble energy and is very bright, but it's less sibilant and harsh than the 2500 was at the same time. The bass depth and control are something special, the mids are a bit colored but fluid, and the openness and clarity are unreal, for the price anyway. I can't believe I got something like this for $35 during that crazy A250 old stock clearance sale. It costs a quite bit more on the used market now, but even at the old retail price of $250 this would still have been a good value phone (if you like its sound that is).

The ESP950 according to trustworthy sources is a fantastic headphone, world-class in the right rig but that horrid E90 amp that it comes with isn't doing it any favors. Ditch that, get a good 'stat amp that's biased to 620/630V (don't remember what exactly) rather than the standard Stax 580V, and the ESP950 should sing. I'm getting a set too at some point, I've been curious about it for ages. If it's voiced like the A250 but doesn't have the A250's colorations, it would be killer for metal!
post #212 of 225
If I get the GMP 8.35's before I see any other posts here on them, I'll chime in with some basic impressions. Just to control expectations, I don't think I'm capable of hearing and describing sound the way Catscratch can. Wow! I don't think I put that much effort and detail into my dissertation. I think I'll need a few decades before I reach that point.

Watching the "This is Spinal Tap" blu-ray at the moment. Picked it up a couple of weeks ago. If you've seen it it sounds great with the DTS-HD sound. Unfortunately there's not much you can do with a picture from 1982. If you haven't, what are you doing on this thread? Kidding, of course, but it's one of my favourite movies. I highly reccommend it.
post #213 of 225
Hmm, suspect this might be a more hardcore thread than I'm ready for, but I also have my eye on the SRH840 for its balance between bass impact and detail : I know the 3-minute guitar solo isnt a big part of thrash/black/death metal, but its a guilty pleasure for geriatrics like myself. Azahoth, the reviews that I have read of the SRH840 sound very promising, and they are under $300 here in Oz, putting them well within your USD budget.

I don't have a lot of metal beyond the older Priest/Sabbath stuff (and every album Deftones ever made, metal or otherwise), but I really wish that Devil Driver would capitalise more on their musicianship. The lead-in to 'End of the Line' is superb - their drummer is a virtuouso muso, IMO - but I've never been a huge fan of Farfara's vocals. Opeth present another challenge for your kit - growling vocals that go straight to an acoustic interlude and back with no lead-in : I'm hoping that my new Ultrasones will bring all of this to life : will post initial impressions Monday night with something more specific after listening to my Mudvayne/Deftones/DevilDriver/Opeth albums (sorry, no Metallica/Anthrax/Slayer at my place).

(mods, if this post offends anyone with an I.P. address in Norway, please delete it post-haste )
post #214 of 225
Thread Starter 
Good to see you back, catscratch!

Quote:
Originally Posted by catscratch View Post
However that T-amp isn't doing your Lambdas any favors and some of the bass lightness you refer to could easily come from that. The transformer box doesn't really have much of a voicing of its own beyond softening up the bass and rolling off the highs slightly. The rest of the voicing comes from the amp, and you want to make sure that it is a good one.
This interested me, so I pulled my big receiver out and hooked the Stax transformer box to that instead. The first thing I noticed is that I really had to give the volume knob a crank to get enough power to the earspeakers. The transformer box must be fairly inefficient.

The second thing I noticed is, yes, there is more bass with the speaker amp driving it. I'm giving it a listen right now, and the difference is somewhat small, but welcome. With the low end enhanced, the music is more enjoyable and dynamic. Bass guitars in particular seem to be better defined.

Quote:
Originally Posted by catscratch View Post
The Omega 2 is calling you. You know it!
I do know it! Luckly I'm helping my friend find a set right now, so I'll get to bum some listening time off of him hopefully. And then I'll have a whole new set of impressions to share...

With regards to the Koss ESP950's, I had a chance to hear Grawk's pair at Canjam, albeit briefly. They had quite a bit of midbass which was nice for guitar distortion, but I didn't think they had the same extension and clarity as the Omega 2's did. They didn't have the proper voltage bias, since they were running off of the Blue Hawaii SE at the Headamp table, so that's something to take into account. Then again, I'm not sure that the extra ~8% in bias voltage would make them significantly better either. It's a headphone that I wouldn't mind having for a review, though. Anybody have one they want to lend? :

My favorite setup at CanJam was at the Whiplash Audio table. They had the Omega2 Mk2, the SRM-007tII tubed amp, and a Sony XA5400ES as the CD player. The bass was excellent -- deep, clear, and fast -- and the imaging was superb. In particular, I remember listening to Megadeth's "Mary Jane," and the beginning has probably an 80/20 split of Mustaine's voice between the right and left ear, respectively. The effect was spooky, and Mustaine's voice sounded incredibly realistic throughout all of the songs I heard. Since I also heard the same headphones and songs on the Blue Hawaii SE at the Headamp table, I can only assume that the source is a lot more important than the amp. The Headamp setup really didn't impress me at all, sorry Justin!

Enough rambling for now. The Stax Lambda's improved for me when using the outputs of my receiver rather than the T-amp, so thank you for the suggestion, catscratch!
post #215 of 225
I kinda like the D2000 for trash metal
post #216 of 225
Thread Starter 
Do you have anything you can share with regards to speed, Eugene? What do you like about the D2000 for thrash?
post #217 of 225
Thread Starter 
I thought I'd go ahead and rank the headphones I've listened to so far based on scale of 0 to 100. Mind you, this is going to be entirely related to how the headphones perform for thrash metal exclusively. So before someone tells me the HD 800's are so good for country music that you can smell the ragweed... I'm not trying to knock any headphones here.

I'll start with the best I've heard, the Stax Omega2's (pick your flavor) as my 100 point. If something else comes along that I like better, I'll change the scale. Otherwise, I'd like to keep adding to it as I listen.

100 -- Stax Omega 2
80 -- Ultrasone Pro 900 / Stax Lambda original model (depending on bass preferences)
70 -- Sony MDR-SA5000 (balanced) / Sennheiser HD 800 (recabled, balanced)
68 -- Sennheiser HD 800 (balanced)
55 -- Grado RS2
50 -- Headphile Terminator V4 / Apple earbuds / Ultrasone Hfi-450
45 -- Sennheiser HD 600 (balanced) / Grado SR80
40 -- Sony MDR-SA5000 (single-ended)
40 -- Beyerdynamic DT770 / 80ohms
25 -- Sony MDR-V6

Missed the cut: Deep-cup Headphile Terminators, cheap-o full size Sony headphones, Sony Qualia, Grado SR325i
post #218 of 225
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris19 View Post
I thought I'd go ahead and rank the headphones.....

...
Hey Chris, nice summary of the thread. Been following this quite closely. Good to see the highly underrated RS2 make the list.

From what I have read in the thread so far, I know you have heard the PS1000 in meet conditions. Are you still waiting to audition them in proper conditions before passing judgment?
post #219 of 225
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by RationalGaze View Post
From what I have read in the thread so far, I know you have heard the PS1000 in meet conditions. Are you still waiting to audition them in proper conditions before passing judgment?
I actually haven't thought about the PS1000 for a while. If I go to a meet where they are lying around, then sure, I'll pick them up and take a listen! But as it was, the Moon-Audio table at CanJam (and the rest of that room) was really packed and a bit noisy. They did have a pleasing sound, though--a bit like full-range speakers. They didn't have the leaping, lightning fast speed of electrostats; that much I could tell. They sounded nice, absolutely. $1700 nice? No sir, I would take my money to electrostats at that point.

Come to think of it, there is another headphone I want to try -- the Audeze planar headphones. Anybody in the San Diego area have these, or are planning on having them soon? Maybe we can arrange a short-term trade of some kind.
post #220 of 225
Chris, when you say 80 - Stax Lambda you speaking of the sr-202/303/404 or the old lambdas?
post #221 of 225
Thread Starter 
I have the original model Stax Lambda. I edited the list to reflect that point, thanks. I should add that I'm using the SRD-7 transformer box with it, powered by my home theater receiver.
post #222 of 225
Thread Starter 

Pro 900 update

So, I finally have my Ultrasone Pro 900's back, and therefore I've had some time to fiddle with them.

Hard-wiring the Blue Dragon cable for balanced operation actually made too much bass with these--it was resonating and making a honky sound. I used a variation of the Kees mod to dampen the cups a little bit, and now the bass is back to being deep, rich, and clean.

The variation consists of just using one cotton round pad (one of those packages you can find in the cosmetics section of a store) pulled in half, and using double-sided tape to fix it against the back of the earcup. One pad = application for 2 earcups. I tried using the felt pads in the way Kees described, but I think this way is best. I'll put some descriptions and pictures up on my other thread this weekend, hopefully.

Also: Megadeth's new album "Endgame" is already streaming in full on their Myspace page. I was totally duped by this Youtube video that claimed to be the new Megadeth instrumental. It's not, it's DeadXheaD, and it's awesome. It's a chop-up of their song "Maximum." Check it out on their Myspace page here. I envy those of you in Europe when it comes to availability of good metal music! I'm importing this CD ASAP.
post #223 of 225

If I may intrude...

Love this thread.

I do have a question, though, in regards to my headphone experiences. Since 95% of my musical preference is metal or similar, I'm seeking the advice of the experts .

I currently use three cans in a given day (in order, top-down, of amount of use):

HD 280
SR60
HD 201

The 280s are at work; sure, I could bring them home for nightly use, but rather not tempt fate . I typically use them a minimum of 3-4 hours a day while programming. The problem is that they just get tiresome; not in terms of listening, but rather their size. They just feel so large and heavy after a while.

At home, I typically reach for the SR60. Love the sound, but on-ear headphones have always caused my ears pain after an hour and a half of use. They are great up until that point, but I have to turn to a full sized, circumaural can at that point if I wish to continue listening.

As you can see, that leaves me with the 201s. While that was nice for initially entering the "I want better equipment" phase a few years ago when I was first watching this site for advice, it just doesn't cut it now. I'm looking to replace them, but given the size of the HD 280s I'm just not sure what I should aim for.

Which brings me to the point of this interruption:

In all these thrash metal-based tests you've done, what's been most comfortable for you from a full sized can that performs worthwhile/quality output? Do you find any style/brand that fits particularly well for extended use, or has it been a bit variable? On that note, if I find the 280s to be a bit heavy am I screwed (aka are all the better quality ones a bit heavier)?

Thanks (sorry if this is too much of a derail).

(PS - Big Megadeth fan here, so I really enjoyed the read/methodology used. I should pick up the new album, but I've been on too much of an Iron Maiden and Judas Priest kick lately.)
post #224 of 225
Thread Starter 

Apologies!

Hey Orthancstone,

I'm sorry, but I've been away from head-fi since my university semester started. I wonder what I've missed? Oh well, I'm broke, so I couldn't afford whatever I missed anyway

Anyways, you present an interesting question for us all--do we have to trade off sound quality for comfort when listening to (thrash) metal?

No, I don't think we do, but it depends on what kinds of colorations you are willing to live with, how long you expect to wear the headphones at one time, and how much you want to spend.

OK, so I'll start by assuming you don't want to spend more than around $100. I have the same problem you do with regards to on-ear headphones, so I'll just say it's not an avenue worth pursuing. What good are headphones if you can't put them on?

A closed headphone I still really like are the Ultrasone HFI-450's. Great overall sound, little sound leakage, and relatively lightweight. However, the ear cups are padded with some kind of pleather, so they get pretty warm. I'd expect that you would want to pull these off every hour or so for 5 minutes to cool down. It didn't bother me enough to dismiss them just for that.

More comfortable, and even lighter, are the Denon D-1001's. They didn't blow me away with their sound quality, though. It was kind of reserved and polite, meaning heavy distortion on guitars didn't have the rough crunch that I expected of them. They aren't all that "fast" either, meaning the speaker doesn't recover quickly enough between notes to resolve everything. They may not present a visceral enough sound for you, but they're pretty comfy.

If you don't mind shoving things into your ear canal, see if you can find the Apple In-Ear earphones nearby, or maybe the Shure SE110's if you hate Apple stuff. I tried the Apple in-ear monitors for about a week, and while I liked their sound, I've never found in-ear headphones comfortable. If you do, well hey, give them a shot. The Apple store didn't give me any beef when I said I just couldn't wear 'em and wanted to return them.

So, let me suggest you start by looking at the Ultrasone HFI-450's, or the Apple In-Ears if you're interested in some noise isolation. I don't think I would recommend any Sennheisers going forward, simply because once I've heard "fast" headphones, it's distracting to listen to thrash metal with anything else.

If you have an increased budget, let me know, and I can put more thought into the recommendation. Also -- do you have an OK amplifier of some kind? Hey, I'm not picky; I think you're OK running off the headphone jack of your home theater receiver! But it sure beats having something battery powered or even just a soundcard output. Could you let us know what your setup currently consists of?

-Chris
post #225 of 225
Hello Chris. I know I'm ressurecting a dinosaur, but I just have to thank you for your invaluable contribution to this site. This thread is GOLDEN to ALL of us who love hard rock and metal. You have done such a complete and thourough job of your research, that you have made my own search results appear before my eyes, even before I embarked on it. You have saved me TONS of time I simply do not have.
The Pro900s are my target now. Thanks again for your dedication and gift.

PS: I've found NO OTHER music puts such a demand on playback systems as complex metal. Avenged Sevenfold makes speakers and headphones cry with it's complexity btw
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Headphones (full-size)
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › My search for great thrash metal headphones