Quote:
Originally Posted by John Willett 
For me personally, I don't like hyped headphones; I like them to be open and neutral and give me what is really there - if the recording is crap I, want to hear it's crap - that means that if it is magnificent it will show me it's magnificent...
|
I have the same tastes for the most part. That's why I settled on the K-1000 and HP-2. The exception is the GS-1000 (which is fine, this hobby is about enjoyment, lest we forget).
So, according to your tastes, you should not like the HD650 which has a bass hump, attenuated highs, and helps bad recordings to not sound so bad.
The GS-1000 and K-1000 doesn't hide any nastiness. But the HD650/600s definitely do.
Quote:
Originally Posted by John Willett 
Getting back to the neutrality point - the Quad electrostatic speakers were renowned for their neutrality and yet they were wonderful to listen to - probably the best set-up I have ever heard was a pair of the original electrostatics in a stacked arrangement (ie: 4 units, one on top of the other each side to really move the air and extend the bass) back in the 1970's. So accuracy and neutrality need not mean a lack of excitement and involvement - but the excitement and involvement will come more from the original performance and how it was recorded rather than how you play it back; and that's how it should be.
|
Most loudspeakers measure relatively neutral unlike headphones. The listening room is really the key to how they will really sounds unless you plan on listening to them in an anechoic chamber.
I realize some sound or measure more neutral than other, but that is a small piece of the pie.
The best loudspeakers that I've heard were what I believe are the best ever made. The Von Schweikert VR11SEs. I've had that confirmed by some wealthy people that have owned a variety of the most expensive speakers (who put their money where there opinions were) and a couple of members over at audiogon who have been through all of them. I'm certainly not going to get in an argument about it being the definitive "best", but I've heard nothing better, not even close - I will say that

- it disappeared completely and left nothing but the music and upstream component coloration.
My point is I never once even thought of the FR graph when listening to them. It was irrelevant even though they measure flat on paper. Some loudspeakers and headphones can sound sterile and are called more neutral... so I guess my question is, which does the HD800 fall into?
(can you tell I'm just dying to get mine?
)