Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Cables, Power, Tweaks, Speakers, Accessories (DBT-Free Forum) › My new Acculine A1 speakers sound like Grado headphones
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

My new Acculine A1 speakers sound like Grado headphones

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
I recieived these Acculine A1 speakers today and they're blowing me away!

Acculine A1

I had a very specific SQ in mind when I ordered these and that's the Grado HP sound in a near field, desktop speaker. For me this is an exciting, in-your-face, sound with lots of transparency and PRAT. This is not a refined (reticent?) classical music speaker, but I’ve become addicted to classical music played on Grado headphones so I wanted speakers that made Mahler, Mozart and Mendelssohn plus Elliott Carter stand up and sing the same way they do on my SR325i. I coupled the A1s to my Infinity 10" subwoofer and they play very well together though eventually (tomorrow?) I may want to get a smaller desktop sub. I'm listening to the A1s as I write this and I'm coming to the tentative conclusion they may sound even better than my SR325is. Frankly, I didn't expect this. BTW, I'm using a Panasonic SA-XR55 receiver and a Sony SCD CE595 CD player.

The Acculine A1 is almost but not quite a BGC Z-1. Here's an excerpt from the Enjoy the Music review that's linked further down this page:

“BG Corporation Z-1Ribbon tweeters make these different from every other bookshelf speakers I've tried at my desktop. Ribbon tweeters rock. Even at only moderate levels the Z-1's have a unique clarity and articulate character that makes them instantly attractive. I was especially surprised by how well they disappear, since they are not small at 7" by 13" by 9.5". Also the Z-1s create a nice large listening widow. Their image shifts less with head movements than many comparably sized speakers. The Z-1's have a large rear port that can and probably should be plugged for desktop use. But even plugged the Z-1's are a bit huffy in the upper bass. This extra bit of bass and lower midrange energy (I call it the LS35A effect) combined with the ribbon tweeter's airiness gives the speakers a slightly happy-faced harmonic balance. Still, especially if you are an electrostatic or ribbon tweeter fan, you're going to feel very much at home with the Z-1's. At higher volumes the Z1-s hold up well, especially in their upper frequencies with only a bit of extra bass energy.

Fit and finish is very impressive for a $499/pr speaker. My review samples had a rich-looking cherry veneer. For bi-amp bi-wire fetishists the Z-1 has dual gold plated five-way posts. For the rest of us they have straps between the posts.

If you have the room for a largish desktop speaker and like an airy open and very un-cone-like upper frequency presentation the Z-1's could be your ideal desktop monitor. For more info, (technical white papers and other techno jive stuff) go to BG Corp."

If you’re interested in audiophile nearfield speakers, you may want to check out this link:

Enjoy the Music.com High-End Audio Editorial and Viewpoint The Nearfield Articles

Here’s the Stereophile review for the BG Z1:

Stereophile: BG Z1 loudspeaker

For $159 plus $10 shipping (ordered yesterday, got it today, YMMV) the Acculine A1 is the best $169 audio dollars I’ve ever spent -almost all my phones cost more!
post #2 of 20
Wow. Nice find. I wonder how this compares to the Swan M200MKII or the D1080.
post #3 of 20
Do you find that these sound good throughout your room?
post #4 of 20
Thread Starter 

Apples and oranges

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alai View Post
Wow. Nice find. I wonder how this compares to the Swan M200MKII or the D1080.
Since I already have a sub and several receivers I’m more interested in unpowered speakers. Also, I was looking for audiophile, nearfield speakers that cost less than $500 and the Swans are designed for those who are stepping up from inexpensive desktop speaker systems. In any case the Audio Adviser makes it very easy for you to answer your own question because they offer very good (unbiased?) advice over the phone and have a 30 day audition period so the most you'd be out is the cost of shipping.
post #5 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by malldian View Post
Do you find that these sound good throughout your room?
Yes, but my answer is meaningful only if you know the size of my room which about 12’X13’X8’.
post #6 of 20
Alright cool. Any idea what the upgraded version is like? I might end up doing a trial on these.
post #7 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by malldian View Post
Alright cool. Any idea what the upgraded version is like? I might end up doing a trial on these.
According to The Audio Adviser "the Acculine A1R is a compact main loudspeaker of remarkable performance that has been designed to perform best on speaker stands. For a complimenting bookshelf or surround/effects loudspeaker, consider the original A1 compact bookshelf speaker, identical in every way but voiced for close-to-boundary use."

"Designed to perform on stands" his is exactly what I don't want (near field remember?) and for once what I wanted cost $90 less! I have a hunch the difference is the A1 has a rear port which can be plugged and the A1R doesn't but I'm not sure about this.
post #8 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by wae5 View Post
I recieived these Acculine A1 speakers today and they're blowing me away!
I'm coming to the tentative conclusion they may sound even better than my SR325is. Frankly, I didn't expect this.
Welcome to the world of high-quality speakers. From what I can see, you can still do much better, though. Of course...$160 a pair is a good price.

Quote:
Originally Posted by wae5 View Post
The Acculine A1 is almost but not quite a BGC Z-1. Here's an excerpt from the Enjoy the Music review that's linked further down this page:
The Acculine A1 is a totally different speaker with a different crossover and a different box and woofer. This is like comparing the Alfa Romeo 159 to the Chevrolet Camaro because they share the same basic engine design.
post #9 of 20
this is interesting to hear. to what speakers do you make comparison? i have seen these speakers before and the prospect of such an inexpensive ribbon bookshelf seemed enticing but i was highly skeptical of their quality.
post #10 of 20
They are quality speakers and normally $300? even for these smaller ones. Fine sound but not for anything more than near field or rear surround duty. You will get speed and detail from them. Do not be concerned about the build quality. They are well made speakers. With the X-LS and other av123 offerings either disco'ed, more expensive, or just plain out of stock lol, this speaker might be the best bang for the buck desktop monitor uner $200 atm. It has my recommendation at least.
post #11 of 20
Would any half-decent source do for these? I mean, heck, I can walk down to one of the many antique stores around here and pick up a receiver for cheap.
post #12 of 20
I'm really on the walls right now between these A1, AudioEngine A2, Swan M200MKII, Swan M10, and Swan D1080MKII.

I know this is a lot of choices, but those seem like the best bang for the buck under the $200 mark.

I know they all sound good, but this will be for my desktop setup in a small 10x10 room in my apartment.
I loveeee bass, btw. I have some crappy creative subs right now which I could hook up to any of the above 2.0 setups, but I will probably be upgrading that in the near future.

Let me know if you guys got some advice, thanks.
post #13 of 20
For a small room, A1, A2, (since you're getting a sub) D1080MKII are your best choices.

Here's how I would categorize these.

Musical Emphasis (particuarly liquidy music like jazz, classical, etc.): A2

Movie/Game or Fast Musics (like Techno or really busy rock songs, etc.) Emphasis (due to quick titanium drivers): A1

All-Arounder (if you add a sub later on because these pretty much have no bass): D1080MKII
post #14 of 20
Ok. now i have to choose between the A1 and the Magnepan MMG W.

I mostly listening to fast electronica and it has to be "fun"

I dont need much bass just that wonderful midrange in the 225s if thats possible. "edgy""raw""fast""screamy"

And i do live in Norway. Would i pay my but of to get them shipped here?
post #15 of 20
Anyone looking to sell their pair?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Cables, Power, Tweaks, Speakers, Accessories (DBT-Free Forum) › My new Acculine A1 speakers sound like Grado headphones