Head-Fi.org › Forums › Misc.-Category Forums › Music › The Beatles or Pink Floyd.....Cast your vote
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Beatles or Pink Floyd.....Cast your vote - Page 12

post #166 of 192

I have to say that Pink Floyd wins in my book. It is hard to compare two different groups like these two. The Wall is just amazing. (It holds a great musical and poetic importance for me.)

post #167 of 192

Definitely Beatles

post #168 of 192

Definitely Pink Floyd for me.

post #169 of 192
Floyd, dark side of the moon. Makes me want to climb into the music and go on a psychedelic journey.
post #170 of 192

Pink Floyd. Roger Waters' writing is incredible, and David Gilmour is a warlock on the guitar. Probably my favorite band of all time actually. 

post #171 of 192

Pink Floyd! I like stuff from Syd Barrett to post break up, and I love the Division Bell album. Probably my most favorite album in my collection. I still love the Beatles tho.

post #172 of 192
Pink Floyd, the beetles bore me for the most part.
post #173 of 192

Beatles released 6 solid albums throughout their career.

>Rubber Soul

>Revolver

>Sergeant Pepper's

>Magical Mystery Tour

>The White Album

>Abbey Road

 

Pink Floyd released 7.

>The Piper at the Gates of Dawn

>A Saucerful of Secrets

>Atom Heart Mother

>Meddle

>Dark Side of the Moon

>Wish You Were Here

>Animals

 

My vote's for Pink Floyd.

post #174 of 192

The Beatles no doubt.

 

You can ask most stupid kids wondering around the streets "Hey do you know who The Beatles are?" and most of them will know, I can't say the same for most about Pink Floyd.  Both are great obviously. 

post #175 of 192

Their styles are too different to compare really. Beatles is about teen love songs, Pink Floyd "geek" psychedelic/space rock.

post #176 of 192
Quote:
Originally Posted by matti620 View Post
 

Their styles are too different to compare really. Beatles is about teen love songs, Pink Floyd "geek" psychedelic/space rock.

 

 

Pink Floyd "geek"? No way, man. You need to watch some documentaries or something to see what they were really about. 

post #177 of 192
For me, today it's The Beatles 'cause my daughter recently 'discovered' them and added dozens of their songs onto her iPod...kinda nice to be able to share that interest with her.

Floyd is great too. I've even seen them live. They're just not on top of my rotation at this time.
post #178 of 192
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flindark View Post

Beatles released 6 solid albums throughout their career.
>Rubber Soul
>Revolver
>Sergeant Pepper's
>Magical Mystery Tour
>The White Album
>Abbey Road

Pink Floyd released 7.
>The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
>A Saucerful of Secrets
>Atom Heart Mother
>Meddle
>Dark Side of the Moon
>Wish You Were Here
>Animals

My vote's for Pink Floyd.
Let it Be don't rank as a solid album?
post #179 of 192

Unfortunately no, IMO. too many weak songs on it.

post #180 of 192

Down right Pink Floyd!

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Music
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Misc.-Category Forums › Music › The Beatles or Pink Floyd.....Cast your vote