[Short Review] ATH-AD700 vs. MS-1 - Page 4

i'm not...yet

.

Edited by WarriorAnt - 4/9/12 at 4:27pm

I'm really enjoying my AD700. The sound has definitely warmed up over the ten days of listening to music 5 hours a day and burn in (using pink noise and a freq wave, started after listening in the beginning and now I'm up to about 30 hours). I'd consider an amp, but I'd need something to reduce the volume down because my comfortable listening level straight out of my MBP is at half volume, lol! I'd buy a resistor to raise impedance to do that, right? Like using the P to S chord that Ety sells for their ER4?

This is an old thread. ZOMBIE THREAD! RISES FROM THE GRAVE TO PICK YOUR BRAINS!

I recently bought MS-1 2009 version and I think they are good headphones. I do agree with what's said about MS-1 in this short review... They are really forward sounding headphones with detail sounds but all "in-your-head". Good tight bass and fast... but the problem I found was also that the mid to high range dominate in most songs and the "deep" portion of the bass tends to be forgotten a bit... MS-1's bass lights up with songs containing more bass. This isn't a problem with MS-1's bass, its only that MS-1's mid to high range dominate more with detail sounds. I have a feeling that the sound stage may be improved in this version though but I haven't own a old MS-1 for a comparison.

I was looking at AD700 but thought I'll give a shot with MS-1 2009. According to reviews I might have enjoyed AD700 little more because of the better sound stage and the good frequency separation... However, because everyone agrees that AD700 tends to be lazy in the bass department AD700 may not be the ideal.

Btw, does anyone know of a headphone set that combines goods of both MS-1 and AD700 with little more focus on the bass department, and that does not brake the bank of course?

I wish I did, because that's exactly the phone I'm looking for. Preferably one also having even more refinement than both.

Might have to go up to MS-Pro, which is a considerable jump up in price. I'd like to stay under $500, but maybe they come up on the used market.

I thought the Denon D-series might do it, but I think the bass would be too overpowering (and they're closed).

The AD900 perhaps comes closest, but to me those sounded "artificial" compared to the MS-1, which I found more organic sounding.

AKG K240 or 701/2? RS-1 or 2? I just don't know what the answer is.

I am also looking for something that combines the AD700 and MS-1 sound. I have a feeling the closest would be the MS-Pro or AD900. In what way did the AD900 sound artificial?

I really don't like my AD700s that much, they're not that exciting. I hope after burn in they'll improve.

Stumble on this thread while trying to decide between AD700, SR80i, and HD555...still not entirely sold but leaning more toward AD700.

hey there!

so how did your AD700 sound after burn in (i figured i'd ask since your post was bout 3 months ago).

I have my AD700 in the burn in stage right now, and I too dont find it exciting. I'd reach for the sr80i or the A500 many times more than the AD700.

However, they do make classical music come to life!

cheers!

I'm having trouble picking between the two :/

I just want something comfy and fullsize for relaxing, listening to music and movies.

I have PortaPros modded into a full size shell and they sound amazing, so it makes it harder for me to pay $50+ more for a set of phones that may or may not be better.

Thanks for the review (from a few years back, according to the dates!). Still struggling to pick one or the other. I also want features from both, the comfort of the ATs, and the sound signature to be somehow a hybrid of both. My music tastes lean towards the MS1s, but I also listen to a lot of acoustic stuff that would benefit from the AT's greatly.

Acoustic material sounds fantastic on the MS-1s. Not sure where you get the idea that the ATs would be better than the MS-1s at that. The MS-1s, with stock comfy pads at least, are also more comfortable long term. The ATs are huge and annoyingly rub your face and neck, they get very hot in summer, and you can't adjust the headband like you can the grado/MS-1s. I would strongly recommend MS-1 with your concerns.

You've sold me! Now just need to make sure what problems I may have at UK Customs... I've searched quite a bit but very few people have talked about how much they had to pay in customs.

 

 

Ha I finally read this after getting both phones, and I'm bumping a really old thread by doing this, but I enjoyed your review.

 

I agree with the lack of bass, but I haven't noticed the recessed vocals as of yet.  Need to do more stress testing.  But most everything else seems very right.

 

Recommendations on what to listen to for hearing the recessed vocals on the AD700?  Thanks in advance.