Quote:
Originally Posted by Lloyd297 
I agree that most super-expensive audiophile speakers do not touch the sound of a live snare but that doesn't mean ALL speakers have the same failing. My point is that powered monitors can actually do a pretty good job of it AND at a much lower price as well.
For years, I've heard live drums and thought my system gave a very weak impression of the explosive transients and speed the live drums provided. But now I can listen to them and feel I'm getting a fair proportion of their liveness, thanks to the 6328's capabilities.
|
This seems to be a slightly different point than you made originally, which is what I was responding to:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lloyd297 
Which is why I think spending three or four grand on a headphone system is ludicrous because I happen to want my system to sound as close to live as possible. Anybody who thinks their Lambdas or Sigmas are accurately doing drums just go and listen close-up to a live snare-drum and swear the difference isn't massive.
|
If you stated your preference was for powered monitor speakers, especially regarding the sense of liveness they give you, than I probably wouldn't have responded - I've heard many a powered monitor that sounded great and they do lend themselves to more of a room/slam sound than a small pair of headphones provides.
That notwithstanding, all of these choices are going to have failings in one area or another if you are going for the live experience, so you just gotta pick your poison. Stating that one of the alternatives is ludicrous because you prefer another is a bit extreme though, but maybe I'm reading more into it than you meant - If you meant ludicrous for you, given your preferences, then in that case, I can't fault your reasoning for the choices you've made.
I'd have to say I enjoy a good speaker rig as much as headphones, but for different reasons. And headphones are far more practical for me, and at this point I sway more for the detail and presentation I get from them then with speakers. I worked in a studio with some awesome JBL powered monitors hung from the ceiling that really had impact, and loved them. I was using Mackies for a while as well (now gathering dust for the most part until I get a place with more room).
At some point I'll be venturing back into the speaker realm some more (right now I have PSB Stratus Golds, which have slam for days, but I have been seduced by a good pair of full range drivers with a subwoofer as well). For now, though, it is my headphone collection that gets my mojo running the most, and the K1000s, coupled with my vivid imagination are what gets me immersed in music the most right now. (The 4070s are actually my pick at the moment, but I have to admit they sound like a miniature band floating around my head, where the K1000s have more presence and slam and "liveness" to the drums).
-- Gordie