Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphone Amps › Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10 added RSA SR-71B
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10... - Page 197  

post #2941 of 3234



Anything to help a fellow head-fier. People have helped me in the past. Cheers friend

Quote:
Originally Posted by swbf2cheater View Post

ohh! i appreciate that! I pmed him, hopefully that guy didnt sell it :)

post #2942 of 3234
The Headsix is indeed a lovely little amp and the value proposition is near impossible to beat. That being said, the Stepdance takes the air in the soundstage to the next level with the ES5. For me, there is no going back. I actually prefer the Stepdance form factor with the iMod. Battery life however is another story...

All this talk of the Mustang is telling me that I should spend some more time with it...
post #2943 of 3234

No love for Ibasso? Many people prefer the Toucan to the Protector and it does have significantly more power at less than half the price. It is also fully balanced, and the Protector is only single ended in. You can even buy a portable balanced DAC to go with it, the Boomslang. The Toucan has been compared to the Lisa III and found comparable, but much less fatiguing to listen to.

 

For single ended power from Ibasso, there is the P4, which outputs 600mw per channel, even more than the Mustang I imagine, again for much less money at $245. That much power will pretty much power any phone near its limits. Finally, the D4 or D12 are very capable amps with good DACs inside them, again for reasonable prices. 

 

I guess the one disadvantage all these amps have in common are the size. They are pretty big, like an Ipod classic only twice as thick. Review Headphoneaddicts rule above, but I still think they are a good deal.


Edited by GeorgeGoodman - 12/9/10 at 7:33am
post #2944 of 3234

he sold it NUUUUUUUUUU

 

*rocks back and forth in the corner twitching

post #2945 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by swbf2cheater View Post

he sold it NUUUUUUUUUU

 

*rocks back and forth in the corner twitching


Look how long it had been posted. Run full speed into the wall a couple of times, you'll be fine. This is all an illusion anyway. Nothing is real, nothing exists . . . . .

 

 

well the amp did but you missed it. 

 

I am listening to a fi.Q that that turns up the heat on anything that is called portable. There's always hope and the Pope. 


Edited by jamato8 - 12/13/10 at 2:44am
post #2946 of 3234

lol <3

post #2947 of 3234

@skylab: aren't you going to review FA Mistify? biggrin.gif

post #2948 of 3234
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by i_djoel2000 View Post

@skylab: aren't you going to review FA Mistify? biggrin.gif



I don't plan to, no.  I'm going to post the review of the Triad Audio L3 in a few minutes, and them I'm going to review the RSA SR71B.  At this point, I intent that to be my last portable amp review, and I will focus my head-fi reviewing efforts on other headphone gear.

post #2949 of 3234
Thread Starter 

Triad Audio L3

Info: Welcome to TriadAudio.net

I got the opportunity to review the updated, slightly smaller version of the Lisa III, which is called the L3.  The L3 is a tiny bit smaller than the original Lisa III, but not much.  It’s still bigger and heavier than any other amp in this roundup.   But a few good things have happened.  One is that there are now both RCA inputs and a front mini-jack input.  This is good for a portable amp.

 

It should be noted that what I reviewed is a pre-production unit.  While I have been told the circuitry will not change at all, I have been informed that a slightly smaller and lighter chassis will be used in the production version.

 

Some pics, nonetheless:

 

L3 Prototype Black Anodize (8).JPG

L3 Prototype Black Anodize (14).JPG

L3 Prototype Black Anodize (11).JPG




Build Quality: A: big and heavy, but well built, for sure.  Again, can't comment too much on the case, ans it will change. Having both RCA and mini-jacks is nice. There was only the very slightest turn-on transient. 

 

Treble: A+: The treble is very clean, extended, airy, sweet, detailed…it’s really a pleasure.  The trick here is the combination of sweetness, delicacy, and detail.  A hard trick to muster, and it’s just special on the L3.  It’s one area in which it’s a little better than the Meier Stepdance.


Midrange: A+: Again, the L3 is pretty special here.  The midrange is open, lush, inviting, and very transparent. It’s not the least bit grainy, or opaque.  It is just slightly lush, and a tiny bit romantic, but not in a way that seems colored.  Still, it seems just ever so slightly less neutral, in the strictest sense, than the Meier Stepdance.  But you wouldn’t kick it out of bed for eating crackers, I can assure you.  The midrange is beguiling.  Alison Krauss's ultra-delicate vocals on "It Doesn't Matter" come across in an incredibly lifelike way.


Bass: A+: The incredibly well implemented bass contour control is one of the nicest features of this amp.  The user can choose the bass weight.  And since the bass quality is excellent - it's well defined, tight, and has outstanding "speed" and attack – you get outstanding performance in just the amount of weight you prefer, or your headphones need.  A little extra bass helped the Beyer t50p immensely.   And the L3’s bass is as deep as your headphones can go.  The flexibility here, married to the outstanding quality, is really something I wish all portable amps had. The ultra-deep synth on The Corrs "The Right Time" is reproduced in full measure, and with a breathtaking robustness.


Neutrality: A: I struggle with the rating here.  With the bass contour knob, the slightly sweet treble, the lightly lush mids – is the L3 really “neutral”?  Thing is, when you listen, it sounds incredibly natural, and you don’t hear anything you’d ever call a coloration.  But I think the Meier Stepdance is slightly more neutral, strictly speaking.


Soundstaging: A+: The soundstage is outstanding, with a depth and definition that I found very addictive.  In reading my original Lisa III review, it seems to me that whatever circuitry changes occurred in the L3 (and there were some, according to Phil Larocco) have helped the L3 in this regard.  The image realism on the L3 is palpable.  I could really get an amazing sense of the hall on"Little Sadie" from the recent Jerry Garcia / John Kahn acoustic release, where you have just acoustic guitar, stand-up bass, and Garcia signing.  But the sense of the two of them in a real space was pretty impressive.


Transparency: A+: Absolutely grain and veil free.  As transparent as you could hope for.

 

My original review of the Lisa III is more than 3 years ago.  It’s been more than two years since I had heard one.  And I was reminded, on auditioning the L3, just how very special this amp is.  I gave up on it due to the size and weight, but for people who just want ONE amp, meaning no home amp, the L3 may just be the very best choice there is out there – powerful enough to drive even the LCD-2, and with some authority, I might add, and competitive with some home amps, in a batter powered form factor that is, at the least, highly “transportable”.  The L3 really is a special amp.  It certainly remains in the top tier of amps on this list.

 

I am going to compare it to the RSA SR71B next week, and compare the two of them again to the Meier Stepdance, which in a kind of cool way will mean I will end my portable amp review monster with a face-off of true top-tier performers.  Lucky me!

post #2950 of 3234
Another great review. (I will wait for the shoot out.)
Edited by cooperpwc - 12/11/10 at 7:38am
post #2951 of 3234

I loved the LISA III very much when I had it. I just did not think it did the job with the T1 so it had to leave me to help finance the Concerto.

But I really miss it and maybe the L3 could be the portable companion to the Concerto...or maybe the Stepdance? I am looking forward to read the face-off. normal_smile%20.gif

post #2952 of 3234

PLease review the P4 warbler :(

That'd be great

post #2953 of 3234
Another great review. Headfi wouldn't be the same without you.
post #2954 of 3234
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by moodyrn View Post

AAnother great review. Headfi wouldn't be the same without you.



Thanks man!

Oh and just a clarification, since someone else asked - I'm still planning to write lots of reviews on head-fi! Just not portable amps wink.gif
post #2955 of 3234

Skylab, do you know it the DC input uses the same LLP power supply that the Lisa lll does?

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Portable Headphone Amps
This thread is locked  
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphone Amps › Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10 added RSA SR-71B