Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphone Amps › Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10 added RSA SR-71B
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10... - Page 185  

post #2761 of 3234
I was wonder if the ibasso toucan was more bang for the buck than a rsa p51 mustang and is any amp worth it for a cowan s9.
post #2762 of 3234
Thread Starter 

OK, thanks.  I have no experience with either the Toucan, or the Cowan, so I cannot help.

post #2763 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skylab View Post

........I have two other reviews to finish, one for the Meier Stepdance, and a DAC review, then I will see if Ray wants to loan me a SR71b for a spin...


which DAC is that? 

post #2764 of 3234
Thread Starter 
The Yulong D100.
post #2765 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skylab View Post

The Yulong D100.


post #2766 of 3234
Thread Starter 

REVIEW: Meier Audio Stepdance


Jan Meier was kind enough to send me an early production sample of his new Meier Stepdance portable amp.  The Stepdance is the first Meier Portable to use his “Balanced Ground” topology.  It’s designed as a performance-first portable amp, which means it has very few features (for example, Meier’s normal Crossfeed is omitted), and it also uses battery faster than his other amps, again with the goal of providing maximum sonic performance. In my opinion, this goal is achieved for sure.

Info: http://www.meier-audio.homepage.t-online.de/


Build Quality: A: Very attractive and sturdy chassis – same other Meier portables.  The amp is very well built, and looks nice.  I subtracted the “+” from the A because I am not fond of the Meier battery door, and I also don’t like the slight rounding of the chassis, as it makes mating with an iPod for portable use a little difficult.  But this is really picking nits.

 

Treble: A+: The treble is smooth, delicate, extended and transparent.  Compared favorably to the very extended but smooth treble of the Qables iQube, and slightly bettered the RSA P51 Mustang.  Small little nuances were registered cleanly, but there was nothing at all aggressive about the highs.  Cymbals are rendered with a smoothness and naturalness that belies the level of extension and detail that is also very much in evidence.


Midrange: A+: Superbly open, transparent, and clean sounding.  The mids were smooth and enjoyable, if just very slightly warm, although there were times I thought I heard a little extra warmth, and times I felt they were nothing short of completely neutral.  In any case the mids were very seductive and natural sounding for sure.  Outstanding for a portable.  Female vocals like Alison Krauss’s on “It Doesn’t Matter” sound terrific without being artificial in any way. 


Bass: A+: Full, punchy, and well defined. As deep as you could hope to get from a portable amp – and impressively so at that.  The very deep bass at the end of Porcupine Tree’s “Russia On Ice” was reproduced in full measure.  Phil Lesh’s “Phil Bomb’s” from the recent “Crimson, White, and Indigo” release were also very meaty, but with outstanding control and definition.  The punchy bass from the MFSL remaster of REM’s “Murmer” was very satisfying, as it was from “Open Car” from Porcupine Tree’s “Arriving Somewhere” live release.

 

Neutrality: A+: The overall sound is unfailingly neutral and natural.  Nothing sticks out at all.  It’s a little less dry than the iQube, and a little less plump than the P51 Mustang – right down the middle.  That’s a good place to be.  To a degree I am not used to in a portable, the StepDance really just provides power, and otherwise gets out of the way completely.  The difference between the iPad’s line out and the line out of the NuForce uDAC were easily discernable.


Soundstaging: A+: Great depth and width both, and a very palpable, well defined image. Truly excellent performance here.   Even without the hallmark Meier Crossfeed, I felt the performance in imaging was at the very top of the class.  Nice holographic presentation of Alison Krauss and Union Station’s live recordings.  The sense of all acoustics during the a-capella “Down In The River To Pray” was so startling that I had to pause the recording to make sure I was really hearing that and not some other sound!  Sure enough, there it was.  Impressive.


Transparency: A+:  Generally a Meier strength, and very much so here as well.  I found no hint of grain or messiness.  Just clean, clear, and open sound.  This makes the Stepdance really seem to provide a higher level of performance than I have come to expect from portable amps. 

So do I think the Stepdance achieves its goal of maximum performance from a Portable?  In spades.  The Stepdance is my new reference Portable Headphone Amp, against which the others will be judged.  It sets the bar very high in what can be done in a headphone amp, and rather than put money into features that many users do not want or need, it puts all the emphasis on sonics.  This is a laudable direction.  Are there trade-offs?  Sure.  It ate through a 9V LITHIUM battery in about a week of heavy use.  If you want a battery-sipper, this isn’t it.  While not huge, it’s far from the smallest and lightest portable amp I’ve ever seen.   But combined with the iPad and the NuForce uDAC (via the uDAC’s RCA outs), the sound from a transportable rig was just unbelievably satisfying. 

 

 

The Stepdance is slated to cost $350 USD (270 Euro outside the EU; 305 Euro in the EU).  At that price, and given its performance level, I think the Stepdance also sets the current bar on price/performance ratio. When I compared it to other top amps I currently own, the iQube sounds slightly dry compared to the Stepdance.  Aside from that, the amps are highly competitive - with the iQube being quite a bit larger, but offering (in the V2) a USB DAC option, which the Stepdance does not.  The RSA P51 Mustang is slightly lusher, and a wee bit forward in the mids.  Again, otherwise competitive, although I think the Stepdance is a little more dynamic and a little more transparent, but these are subtle.  The P51 does has the advantage of being smaller.

 

All three of these amps are outstanding.  I would chose them based on the partnering headphones. The P51 works best with the slightly bright t50p, although I very much enjoy the t50p via the Stepdance as well.  The Stepdance was best with the Senn PXC350 and the W1000X, and also did the best job of several of my high-end headphones that I wouldn;t really expect a portable amp to drive.

 

The Stepdance now resides in the top "Level 1" in my rankings: http://www.head-fi.org/forum/thread/214588/review-portable-amp-roundup-37-portable-amps-reviewed-and-compared#post_2585634


Edited by Skylab - 8/20/10 at 6:14am
post #2767 of 3234

Nice. Is this Stepdance unit a pre-production? Thanks.

post #2768 of 3234
Thread Starter 

Yes, as stated, it is an early-production unit.  Production has begun, and availability is in a few weeks, according to Meier.

post #2769 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skylab View Post

Yes, as stated, it is an early-production unit.  Production has begun, and availability is in a few weeks, according to Meier.


Thanks Sky. At $229, can the iBasso Toucan raise the bar even higher on price/performance?

post #2770 of 3234
What about its ability to drive various headphones including iems. I know you are not an iem guy, but a great deal of headfiers on this forum use JH13/16, does it produces hisses on iems? What about difficulty phones like HD600/650 line? What HP did you use? Thanks
post #2771 of 3234
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by wuwhere View Post




Thanks Sky. At $229, can the iBasso Toucan raise the bar even higher on price/performance?



I don't know.  iBasso hasn't sent me a review loaner in a long time (my last iBasso reviews were done with HeadphoneAddict's review samples), and so I have not heard the Toucan.
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jalo View Post

What about its ability to drive various headphones including iems. I know you are not an iem guy, but a great deal of headfiers on this forum use JH13/16, does it produces hisses on iems? What about difficulty phones like HD600/650 line? What HP did you use? Thanks


I used the Beyer t50p, the Sennheiser PXC-350, and the AT W1000X for this review.  Unfortunately, I do not own any IEM's, so I cannot help with that.  I did try the Stepdance with the 600 ohm Beyer T1, and it did a remarkably good job with them, considering it's a battery powered portable - slightly better than my reference portables.

post #2772 of 3234

Skylab, did you commented t50p anywhere at head-fi? I am very interested to know your opinion on these cans.

post #2773 of 3234
Thread Starter 
post #2774 of 3234

Thanks for the review, Skylab. Do you find the 32 volume steps to be sufficient? Sounds a little rough to me - especially for people listening at very quiet volume levels. For an average dynamic range of ~90dB that would mean one step is ~2.8dB.

post #2775 of 3234
Thread Starter 

I did not find it to be a problem, no.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Portable Headphone Amps
This thread is locked  
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphone Amps › Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10 added RSA SR-71B