or Connect
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › Sennheiser HD650 Impressions Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Sennheiser HD650 Impressions Thread - Page 1031

post #15451 of 28397

Did anyone else notice that someone posted a 1 star review of the HD650 yesterday and now its been taken down (I assume by an administrator)? :confused_face(1): 


Edited by PTom - 1/25/14 at 3:21am
post #15452 of 28397

scolaiw: Do you think such "cheap" DAC will be enough? And which would you personally pick Modi or ODAC ( for sound quality for HD650 )?

 

PTom : Maybe he listened to it carefully after posting review and changed his opinion :D

post #15453 of 28397

Missed it.   Was the review legit or was it something like an Amazon review where the reviewers dog chewed on them for an hour then buried them in the back yard and after digging them out the cable was shorting-out from being chewed on and they sounded terrible from having dirt all in the drivers. Of course all this is poor product design and deserves a 1-star rating.

post #15454 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by jojinkho View Post

 

PTom : Maybe he listened to it carefully after posting review and changed his opinion :D

I checked his profile and the review is still a 1 star review but only administrators can access it.

post #15455 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by cswann1 View Post
 

Missed it.   Was the review legit or was it something like an Amazon review where the reviewers dog chewed on them for an hour then buried them in the back yard and after digging them out the cable was shorting-out from being chewed on and they sounded terrible from having dirt all in the drivers. Of course all this is poor product design and deserves a 1-star rating.

It seemed legit from what I remember. It was short but I think his pros were "Good bass" and cons: " Darkest headphones I've ever heard". He's also posted on other threads discussing headphones in general so....

post #15456 of 28397
post #15457 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by jojinkho View Post
 

scolaiw: Do you think such "cheap" DAC will be enough? And which would you personally pick Modi or ODAC ( for sound quality for HD650 )?


Yes, in this case, I do think it is enough. The 650s are very forgiving and both the Modi and ODAC perform exceptionally well at their price range. DAC technology is constantly getting better and it's not worth investing too much unless you will be investing in a much more expensive system. I personally preferred the Modi just slightly over the ODAC (when paired with the WA6), but to be perfectly honest, they perform almost identically to my ears.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by PTom View Post
 

It seemed legit from what I remember. It was short but I think his pros were "Good bass" and cons: " Darkest headphones I've ever heard". He's also posted on other threads discussing headphones in general so....

 

 

And I don't think it was a well thought out review. His review isn't legitimate in that the score did not reflect his comments. Being the darkest headphone ever heard is not enough to warrant a score of 1 star. Would he give the LCD 3s a 0 then?  

post #15458 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by scolaiw View Post
 

And I don't think it was a well thought out review. His review isn't legitimate in that the score did not reflect his comments. Being the darkest headphone ever heard is not enough to warrant a score of 1 star. Would he give the LCD 3s a 0 then?  

I don't think censorship is the answer. People should be allowed to decide on their own whether or not his review is "legitimate".


Edited by PTom - 1/25/14 at 4:53am
post #15459 of 28397
Although I don't agree with it, censorship is ubiquitous on this site. I myself have faced censorship on this site before. It's not like they aren't allowed to do it, since we agree to it when we sign up to the site.

Having said that, since the reviewer did not justify his score of 1, he's not doing himself any favours.
post #15460 of 28397

Most of the censorship on this site is directly related to their sponsors (I too have been censored here in the past), so of course they aren't going to allow half-assed, ill informed, and thoughtless reviews of certain products, regardless of how legit they may seem to the reviewer.

 

I've seen entire threads shut down because of one person talking badly about a certain company.

post #15461 of 28397

Were you planning on building the Crack yourself or buying one already built? I would absolutely get a Crack/Speed and a Modi, or a Bifrost Uber if you could afford it. I think a Crack/Speed and a Bifrost Uber is what I am going to get for my 'end game' setup. I have heard that set and I think you would have to spend a LOT of money to do better.

post #15462 of 28397
Ok everyone it was me, maybe I should have given 2-3 stars but this headphone really disappointed me to know end! I just don't understand why I can't enjoy detail and crisp clean highs at that price level. Now everyone has a different understanding on how they perceive sound, but this headphone just didn't cut it for my tastes, and especially at that price range. I apologize to anyone who thinks the world of the HD650, but for me it will just sit in a box forever in my basement. I love the HD600's very much and was expecting so much more with the newer model, but it just didn't do it for me. I am very willing to have discussions about my choice, but please don't bash me as I am very much in love with headphone audio and appreciate talking to nice people. Thanks so much.
Edited by pedtool101 - 1/25/14 at 11:44am
post #15463 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by dxanex View Post
 

Most of the censorship on this site is directly related to their sponsors (I too have been censored here in the past), so of course they aren't going to allow half-assed, ill informed, and thoughtless reviews of certain products, regardless of how legit they may seem to the reviewer.

 

I've seen entire threads shut down because of one person talking badly about a certain company.

If certain ratings of certain products are being selectively filtered out the headphone rankings/average ratings, IMO, lose credibility. I might even go so far as to call it a form of deception.


Edited by PTom - 1/25/14 at 12:40pm
post #15464 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by pedtool101 View Post

Ok everyone it was me, maybe I should have given 2-3 stars but this headphone really disappointed me to know end! I just don't understand why I can't enjoy detail and crisp clean highs at that price level. Now everyone has a different understanding on how they perceive sound, but this headphone just didn't cut it for my tastes, and especially at that price range. I apologize to anyone who thinks the world of the HD650, but for me it will just sit in a box forever in my basement. I love the HD600's very much and was expecting so much more with the newer model, but it just didn't do it for me. I am very willing to have discussions about my choice, but please don't bash me as I am very much in love with headphone audio and appreciate talking to nice people. Thanks so much.

 

Just remember that we take our reviews here seriously.  It's more then okay to share a bad experience, but I can't imagine the HD650 being a 1 star to anyone.  Even if its not your cup of tea.  Enjoy your HD600s, and there's nothing wrong with not liking the 650's sound signature...

post #15465 of 28397
Quote:
Originally Posted by pedtool101 View Post

Ok everyone it was me, maybe I should have given 2-3 stars but this headphone really disappointed me to know end! I just don't understand why I can't enjoy detail and crisp clean highs at that price level. Now everyone has a different understanding on how they perceive sound, but this headphone just didn't cut it for my tastes, and especially at that price range. I apologize to anyone who thinks the world of the HD650, but for me it will just sit in a box forever in my basement. I love the HD600's very much and was expecting so much more with the newer model, but it just didn't do it for me. I am very willing to have discussions about my choice, but please don't bash me as I am very much in love with headphone audio and appreciate talking to nice people. Thanks so much.

 

The sonic differences between the HD600 and HD650 are very minimal and I've never found that much difference between them. The HD600 is slightly more neutral but the HD650 has the more euphonic sounding to me. 

 

How long have you been using them? Don’t forget the "brain burn-in".  


Edited by pdrm360 - 1/25/14 at 1:49pm
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Headphones (full-size)
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › Sennheiser HD650 Impressions Thread