These conversations are completely worthless. Musical tastes vary more than almost any other personal opinion, and people are swayed or srengthened by way too many factors. I see a lot of people ripping on many bands, like Radiohead, without providing a solid reason as to why. Reasoning doesn't go beyond "I don't get it."
What do you all look for in music? Technical virtuosity? Catchy hooks? Simplicity? Solid rythm and time? Fantastic vocals? Enthralling lyrics?
I like all of those things, but do I always find them in the same place? Of course not. I listen to a variety of things to find what I want to hear at any given time. How or why we put these musicians on the chopping block without good reason is beyond me. Is it just arrogance, exemplified by the whole "punks hating sell-outs" thing? It seems that many find some kind of strange pleasure in bashing popular music; it makes the critics feel superior "knowing" that they are among a select few that listen to a certain musician that is so much better than the trend. We're ready rip on some musician for their faults, while we are so quick to forgive our favorites of their own.
Perhaps we should also be listing the musicians that we find outstanding, and why. I think we'll find that we all like certain musicians for certain reasons. Why we spend time on here bashing music, much of the time without foundation, is an exercise in musical pride that I don't get.
