I'll separate my list into two groups. The first has all the series currently being subbed I'm watching or recently finished. The second has whatever dvds a friend of mine and I are currently watching on our weekly anime night (selected by what we think might be good and random coin flips).
Subbed:
- My-HiME (4.5/5) : Really great series! First half feels more magical girl-ish, though more well-done than usual, and focuses on comedy, character background/motivations, and monster-of-the-week. Characters tend to act more realistic and feel more natural, for a change. Second half... wow. HUGE change in tone, surprising drama everywhere, really well-done. This would've been a 5, but I didn't care for the way they chose to end it (acceptable and conclusive, but could've been much more satisfying). Also has very good music. Highly recommended.
- Bleach (4.5/5) : Another really great series I assume most people have heard of already. Suffice to say it's got great balance (comedy, drama, action) and I see loads of potential. Watched all the anime so far subbed, haven't read the manga.
- One Piece (4.5/5) : Same as for Bleach, though it's heavier on action/comedy, w/ just enough drama to keep the plot going. Also haven't read the manga.
- Naruto (4.25/5) : Same as for Bleach, though it's heavier on action/drama, w/ some comedy in appropriate places. Sometimes the pacing will seem a bit slow, mainly in the worse-than-usual filler episodes. Again, haven't read the manga.
- Honey & Clover (?/5) : Kinda interesting slice-of-life show w/ some comedy. Only seen three eps so far, so too early to give a rating. Has potential, but the niece must be a midget or something.
- Tsukuyomi (2.5/5) : Vampiric cat-girl, main character w/ a backbone, and funny chibi-shinigami = good, but the story has been pretty lacking and generic. Has its moments, but they're not frequent enough, especially since new subbed episodes appear once in a blue moon, pardon the pun.
DVDs:
- Brigadoon (3.25/5) : Kinda weird show dealing w/ two worlds being somehow forced together, Brigadoon and Earth... seen a few discs. Monsters of the week and allies, well they're odd in a comedic sense, but not all that cool. Took a turn for the serious in dealing w/ some real-life types of issues normally not emphasized. Nice opening theme. Lolo is very amusing so far, the Trigun cat has nothing on Lolo.
- Card Captor Sakura (4.5/5) : If I wanted to hope somebody would like the magical girl genre off of just one show, I'd pick this one to show them. Great series, consistently funny and heart-warming. The card-monsters are fairly simple, but they're usually stylish enough. Only people I wouldn't recommend it to are people that automatically hate any cute things.
- Love Hina (2/5) : I have nothing against harem shows in general (ex. I really enjoy Ranma 1/2), but I really hate it when the spineless male lead is getting constantly punched into orbit, for absolutely no good reason, by the b****y female love interest.That alone knocks it down 2 points in my book. To be fair, it does have some decent comedy, though not enough, Mutsumi and Shinobu are decent, and some of the music is good.
- R.O.D. TV (4/5) : I've enjoyed the whole paper-master concept since Yomiko Readman in the OAV, and this just expands on it w/ much more action and drama. The villains are, thankfully, less silly than the OAV (I'm sorry, the final battle in the OAV was just stupid, in both opponent and execution).