Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › Orthodynamic Roundup
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Orthodynamic Roundup - Page 196

post #2926 of 19957
That manual seems to imply that different magnets effect transient response, I thought that only effected efficiency?

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2927 of 19957
Quote:
Originally Posted by wualta View Post
Let's see how this YH-1 auction goes....

... So who got it? I've guessed before and been pratfall wrong, so I ain't guessin'.
... a little bird says that they will be safely within the HeadFi community
post #2928 of 19957
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by GuyMe View Post
That manual seems to imply that different magnets effect transient response, I thought that only effected efficiency?
You're correct. Magnet strength affects only efficiency in an isodynamic driver. The ad copy says "sharper" response with the stronger YHD-1 magnet, and I suppose the difference in sound between the two could be described that way, but transient response is poor in both cases.

Quote:
Originally Posted by billinkansas View Post
... a little bird says that they will be safely within the HeadFi community
That was a given. We only know that it was bought by the owner of a YH-100 service manual...
post #2929 of 19957
Turned out to not have enough felt to fill my orders, so i went back to JoAnn for more.

Noted the existence of Yet Another Grade of Felt.

In addition to the 65% rayon / 35% wool usually referred to here as superfelt, they now also carry an 80/20 blend.

This stuff is thinner, and seems denser, and it's a couple bucks cheaper than superfelt, so i bought some.

However, held up to the light, it seems less evenly dense than superfelt. some parts let in less light than others.

It might work in double layers, or it might be worthless.

I'll mess with it a bit at some point. maybe I'll stick some in an envelope and send it to The Lab.

Edit: I will of course fill my orders using standard 65/35 superfelt. Some people get red superfelt, some people get black superfelt. I originally used only the black, and then couldn't tell the difference between the right and left sides of my phase 2 pro 30. So i bought some red superfelt to line the outer vents on the right side of the pro 30.
post #2930 of 19957
Quote:
Originally Posted by wualta View Post
You're correct. Magnet strength affects only efficiency in an isodynamic driver. The ad copy says "sharper" response with the stronger YHD-1 magnet, and I suppose the difference in sound between the two could be described that way, but transient response is poor in both cases.
This would only be true if the diaphragms were the same and the holes in (and thickness of) the weak and strong magnets were identical. Admittedly the brochure doesn't go into those details, but if the better magnets allowed for differences on either of those marks, then the response could indeed be slightly sharper. Of course, this isn't to say that the sharpness claim might not just be BS.
post #2931 of 19957
Just shoved another stack of 120R SFI drivers out the door.

I have a bit more than half of them left. I've shipped to 5 countries and several states.
post #2932 of 19957
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
This would only be true if the diaphragms were the same and the holes in and thickness of the weak and strong magnets were identical.

Good point-- I should have been careful to say that all other things being equal (which they happen to be in the case of the YHD drivers), magnet strength has no effect on sound quality in an isodynamic driver.

The reason this is true, by the way, is that the voice coil/magnet system has so little BL product (see below) that moving back and forth in the driver's magnetic field creates almost no "back emf"-- a mirror-image (ie, out-of-phase) voltage created by the motion of the diaphragm that resists its motion, or, in other words, damp it. This is a built-in benefit that all dynamic drivers (including speaker drivers) have. Electrodynamic braking, if you will. Or regenerative braking, to borrow an automotive term currently en vogue.

So if a Toyota Prius had orthodynamic brakes, it would crash a lot. Does this mean that every time a dynamic cone is moved by its coil, it turns into a freakin' microphone and tries to back sass the amplifier? it does.

By the way, I've never seen ortho magnet holes so small or magnets so thick that I ever seriously believed they had any effect on diaphragm damping or sound quality, but it's certainly possible. The PWB Dyna-X driver has very thick magnets, for example, but I doubt there's any audible effect on sound quality that wouldn't be completely swamped by enclosure resonances, etc. 

 

Good reading on things like BL product, resonances, all the things we deal with (and, since it's primarily about speakers, some things we don't hafta deal with) from my hero Lynn Olson: http://www.nutshellhifi.com/library/speaker-design1.html

 

Edited by wualta - 2/1/12 at 7:13pm
post #2933 of 19957
Quote:
Originally Posted by wualta View Post
(which they happen to be in the case of the YHD drivers)
Do we know this for a fact? So the brochure's sharpness claim was just marketing hot air?

Quote:
By the way, I've never seen magnet holes so small or magnets so thick that I ever seriously believed they had any effect on diaphragm damping or sound quality, but it's certainly possible. The PWB Dyna-X driver has very thick magnets, for example, but I doubt there's any audible effect on sound quality that wouldn't be completely swamped by enclosure resonances, etc.
Yeah, I doubt it would be a very significant change. Thinner magnets might allow for more room for the diaphragm to produce bass, though. In principle, a driver with tiny holes and thick magnets should be measurably worse than one with a paper-thin magnetic mesh, but in practice the chance that a YHD-1 driver sounds better than a 2 just because of the magnets is slim.
post #2934 of 19957
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
Do we know this for a fact? So the brochure's sharpness claim was just marketing hot air?
Well, what's "sharpness"? What did they mean?

Note that they weren't just shying away from the specific mention of transient response-- they used it elsewhere: "deeply detailed musical transients". So yeah, I think they were trying to justify the extra cost of the YHD-1. They could simply have said it had more bass, which is true, and that would have done the job of selling the YHD-1. So is "sharpness" BS? Not quite. Does it give a clear idea of what the YHD-1 offers? No. Is the transient response any better? No.

I do have both headphones, and though they are slightly different bass-outputwise, they both have the downward tilt and underdamped bass of any other "loose" Ortho. The YHD-1 don't know when to quit-- it has lots of bass, but lousy, floppy bass. Put it in a normal planar enclosure and you'd have a little bass monster, like the HP-50 and YP-3.


Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
Yeah, I doubt it would be a very significant change. Thinner magnets might allow for more room for the diaphragm to produce bass, though.
Well, it would allow a thicker spacer between the magnets with no change in the dimensions of the driver, yeah. Which reduces the flux strength where the diaphragm is, so you use thicker and/or stronger magnets-- same idea as Stax going from Lambda to Lambda Pro. Easy for 'stats. Harder for planar magnetics because the magnets have to get more expensive or heavier or both if you want to give the diaphragm more room to rock.


Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
In principle, a driver with tiny holes and thick magnets should be measurably worse than one with a paper-thin magnetic mesh, but in practice the chance that a YHD-1 driver sounds better than a 2 just because of the magnets is slim.
Right. It's moot, though, because neither headphone stands up well today, despite having a lot of inherent goodness built in. To get the max from either headphone requires a transplant. You might be able to damp the YHD driver in situ and have a decent-sounding minimalist headphone, but you'd have a compromised minimalist headphone. There's not enough room in the minimalist "cup" for more than a couple very thin damping layers, and there are no earpads to sculpt response. They are what they are.

.
post #2935 of 19957
Quote:
Originally Posted by wualta View Post
Well, what's "sharpness"? What did they mean?
good point.


Quote:
I do have both headphones, and though they are very different bass-outputwise, they both have the downward tilt and underdamped bass of any other "loose" Ortho. The earpadless design lops off most of the bass of the YHD-2 but the YHD-1 doesn't know when to quit. Put it in a normal planar enclosure and you'd have a little bass monster, like the HP-50 and YP-3.
What a near-miss the whole orthodynamic moment was. All that potential, and so few implementations that actually worked well out of the box. Half of the grand moral of our thread, I guess.


Quote:
Well, a thicker spacer between the magnets, yeah. Which reduces the flux strength where the diaphragm is, so you use thicker or stronger magnets-- same idea as Stax going from Lambda to Lambda Pro.
genau, just what I was thinking.

Quote:
You might be able to damp the YHD-1 driver in situ and have a decent-sounding minimalist headphone, but you'd have a heavily compromised minimalist headphone.
what do you think this might look like? A puck of felt glued to the back, and something else? Could be interesting. These days I feel like every headphone ever made was heavily compromised, so I think I could live with it.
post #2936 of 19957
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
What a near-miss the whole orthodynamic moment was. All that potential, and so few implementations that actually worked well out of the box. Half of the grand moral of our thread, I guess.
Yes. The YHD Orthos are particularly heartbreaking. Well, the 1 and 2 are. Still haven't heard the 3, though I've heard a 3 variant. The design of the 1 and 2 is so neatokeen, a Definate Coolist Heaphone Evar candidate, that you don't want to rip them apart and gank the drivers for a foster 'phone, but if you want to hear what those drivers can do...


Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
what do you think this might look like? A puck of felt glued to the back, and something else?
Maybe the tiny earpads from the YHE-50, but yes, a puck o' felt would be the extent of it. As you know, the felt disc has three effects: it flattens the response, tightens the impulse (aka transient) response and also acts as a teensy delay line for the bass backwave. There's no room inside the YHD-1/2 "cup" for anything beyond a damping disc, so you'd pretty much have to stop there, whether you got the 1 or the 2. The problem is of course that both are rare (though not ultrarare) on the online auction market.


Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
Could be interesting. These days I feel like every headphone ever made was heavily compromised...
Genau! There are not that many non-zynisch headphones.


Quote:
Originally Posted by facelvega
I think I could live with it.
I think you'd really like the YHD-1 and I hope you can find one.
.
post #2937 of 19957
Quote:
Originally Posted by wualta View Post
Won the HP-3. Thanks, guys. Oddly, I was the only bidder-- it was kinda eerie. .
I know this was a few days ago but I had fully intended to enter the portentous ortho world by winning this bid - I was stuck in a bus and couldn't get a wireless signal . ericj has been feeding me tidbits and I can say that I am feeling myself slide , so I thought I would just say my hello's and that I look forward to this adventure ..dB
post #2938 of 19957
Thread Starter 
Your timing is perfect. The HP-3 arrived today, and the earpads are not so much scummy as well-worn. They remind me of the cover of a prayed-out missal. Won't be able to test 'em til tonight. Welcome to our little moonbeam of the larger lunacy, don't be afraid to ask questions, have a look around.

.
post #2939 of 19957
I suppose that means that my time for procrastination over taking pictures of my YH-3 tweaks is over.

If i can tear myself away from the Bijou / YH-100 combination, I'll go take pictures. Nowish.

And yeah, welcome to our madness, dBel84.
post #2940 of 19957

Yamaha HP-3 / YH-3 Phase 1



Here we see the earcup with vent lining and patented Spring Normalizer covering the ball joint.

I used superfelt for the vent lining and leathery cheap sham-chamois for the Spring Normalizer. All this is doing is covering the big dish the ball joint creates. You could probably use craft paper. Or masking tape.

You should also be able to make out the sometimes-mentioned pins that hold the driver up.

In Phase 2, I am sorely tempted to chop these pins off, not using the Spring Normalizer, and laying a big disc of superfelt across the whole back of the earcup - increasing the vent damping a bit, and allowing me to use a new and better bit of foam rubber.

As you can see in the following picture, the original foam is roughly as sad as you find in the average Pro 30.



What should jump out at you first is the sheer amount of bluetak required to seal this baffle. This is because the nonwoven fabric that protects the driver is loose, held behind a silly paper gasket that is also loose. These will fall out when you open your YP-3 for the first time.

In Phase 2, I am tempted to follow in the footsteps of PMB and glue the fabric to the front of the driver. Or perhaps to the grille. This would allow me to use less bluetak to get a better seal.

The vent lining was made by starting with a disc of superfelt slightly bigger than the diameter of the earcup and then cutting out the outer 1/2 inch. And then cutting about a half inch of the material off one end.

The dual layers of superfelt are small enough to fit between the pins. This annoys me a bunch. Obviously in Phase 2, they'll be bigger, because the pins will be gone.

It might be worthwhile to try using a denser material - such as a scrap of microfiber polishing cloth - as the 2nd layer. I didn't like the yellow polishing cloth as the 1st layer. I always get the impression that it's both damping too much and flopping back and forth like a drum where it lays across the holes in the driver.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Headphones (full-size)

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Headphones (full-size) › Orthodynamic Roundup