Support Head-Fi.org by
starting all of your
Amazon.com shopping by
clicking here.
____________________________________________________________________
Today's Featured Head-Fi Blog: A Japanese headfier's monologue (Sasaki)
____________________________________________________________________
Please help
support Head-Fi by becoming a Contributing Member
CLICK
HERE -- Contributing Members, thank you
for your generous support! --
XP or Vista Basic or Vista Business for fast operation of basic functions
Greetings,
Should I switch from Vista Basic to XP Pro [or Vista Business]? I have a Toshiba Satellite A100 (bottom of the barrel) and I am within reach of Windows XP Professional 32-bit [and Vista Business] through school. I mainly use my computer for the internet and storing notes. I just want something that will do simple things as quickly as possible. MS Office; Mozilla Firefox; foobar2000, iTunes and WMP11; WMP classic for some TV shows; avast anti-virus; ZoneAlarm Firewall (switch to Comodo if I go with XP); Windows Messenger; and HotSync manager for my Palm Treo 680. Here are some cursory specs:
80GB
Intel Celeron
1.86GHz
1.0GB RAM
Specs are at the link, Toshiba Satellite A100. Now, I have Vista and I think I've heard all about how crappy it is. I'm just wondering if I would have faster operation with Windows XP Pro as opposed to Vista. The thing is that I just got comfortable with the way everything is set up (antivirus, firewall, sidebar, folders, music). Is it worth the migration? Would this be a trek to the promised land for me or will it be a wild goose chase? I appreciate any help.
edit: forgot Vista Business.
__________________
"Ears that hear and eyes that see - the LORD has made them both." Proverbs 20:12
Team University-fi | Team Edmonton-and-Surrounding-Urbanities(1)(2)
Rants: - there - in or at that place; to or into that place; at that point or stage; in that matter, respect, or relation; used interjectionally to express satisfaction, approval, encouragement or sympathy, or defiance
- their - of or relating to them or themselves especially as possessors, agents, or objects of an action; his or her
- they're - they are
Well, Vista with Aero will run slower than XP on your machine. Having said that, I don't think you'll notice the difference in performance if all you're doing is basic stuff. If you already setup Vista the way you like it, why not just stick with it.
One recent review I read suggested that XP is twice as fast on certain real-world workloads (on the same machine). Given that you have a modest machine, I'd expect you'd see some speed benefit by going back to XP.
Moderator Headphoneus Supremus: Moderator and SHAman who knew of Head-Fi ten years prior to its existence
Originally Posted by AlanY
One recent review I read suggested that XP is twice as fast on certain real-world workloads (on the same machine). Given that you have a modest machine, I'd expect you'd see some speed benefit by going back to XP.
Exactly. For what the OP needs his comp for I would get XP Pro, update it with all the SPs and then optimize it for performance over visuals. One would have a very nice and fast windows experience.
The other benefit is you'll get somewhat longer battery life with XP, which may be useful being a student. Part of it is increased use of the GPU in Vista, but most of it is Vista spinning the hard drive more (larger working set, that pre-emptive caching scheme that runs continuously to fill empty memory, etc.).
Sounds good, guys. It seems it's a pretty decisive victory for XP Pro here. One drawback I was considering was Vista's awesome hibernate/sleep mode. I can turn on the computer fairly quickly and be up and running in no time, all the while drawing very low power until startup. How does XP's sleep mode compare to Vista's? My friend on XP said his battery drained only 0.5%/hr, while mine is a bit closer to 1%/hr. Is that typical for XP-ed laptops?
__________________
"Ears that hear and eyes that see - the LORD has made them both." Proverbs 20:12
Team University-fi | Team Edmonton-and-Surrounding-Urbanities(1)(2)
Rants: - there - in or at that place; to or into that place; at that point or stage; in that matter, respect, or relation; used interjectionally to express satisfaction, approval, encouragement or sympathy, or defiance
- their - of or relating to them or themselves especially as possessors, agents, or objects of an action; his or her
- they're - they are
Sounds good, guys. It seems it's a pretty decisive victory for XP Pro here. One drawback I was considering was Vista's awesome hibernate/sleep mode. I can turn on the computer fairly quickly and be up and running in no time, all the while drawing very low power until startup. How does XP's sleep mode compare to Vista's? My friend on XP said his battery drained only 0.5%/hr, while mine is a bit closer to 1%/hr. Is that typical for XP-ed laptops?
Sleep and hibernate are the same in both XP and Vista, assuming you have power management (ACPI) drivers for both. (I had ACPI drivers for my 2001 vintage ThinkPad, so it always surprises me when I see laptops from say 2006 with no sleep support. I suppose some hardware vendors just don't care.) Current drain in sleep is going to depend on the laptop hardware, battery chemistry, battery age, etc. It has nothing to do with the OS.
I would definitely "downgrade" to XP Pro SP2, the major selling point of Vista is Aero but with Basic you don't even have that. Aero on a GMA 950 runs, but it's not pretty, especially with 1GB of RAM. Ultimately the best way to make the most of your PC is to use XP which will run faster on your PC.
XP or Vista Basic or Vista Business for fast operation of basic functions
Linear Mode
