Vinnie, you are the man! Thanks for your honest assessment of the new iPod. I would expect nothing less from you. You are truly a gentleman!
__________________
In life, it is more important to enjoy the journey, than to arrive quickly at the destination.
Portable Rig: Etymotic ER4s; Senn 650 (Zu Mobius); Senn 545; PK3; RSA Tomahawk; Total Bithead; RSA SR-71; PA2V2; 60g 4th Gen iMod; 40g 4th Gen iPod; 1g shuffle; ALO cryo; Zu Pivot; DIY by Skyline.
Home Office: Mark Levinson Red Rose Music Spirit Speakers; Berendsen IPA-80 Integrated Amp; Sony DVP-NS9100ES; Musical Fidelity X-DAC, X-PSU, X-10v3; Rega P-3 w/ Super Elys and Musical Fidelity X-LPSv3; Magnum Dynalab MD-90 tuner; DiMarzio and Signal Cable power cords; Audio Quest Coral interconnects; Red Rose speaker cable.
Family Room: Bolder Cable Modified Slim Devices Squeezebox 3 Network Music Player and mod Elpak power supply; Tannoy Saturn Speakers; Paradigm PW-2200; Integra DTR-6.5; Integra DPC-8.5; Signal Cable Silver Resolution and Audioquest Coral.
Bed Room: NAD L53; Paradigm Titan; Signal Cable Classic speaker cable.
Work: NAD L53; Gallo Nucleus speakers and MPS subwoofer; Zu Pivot.
What I read is that the 6g without v-caps, sounds almost as good as a 5g imod w/ v-caps.
Let me clarify this a little (just based on my findings):
The 6G iPod line-out sounds closer to the 5G/5.5G iMod with Vcap Dock than the stock 5G/5.5G line-out does, but saying "almost as good" might be going a little too far and may lead to people being disappointed.
I really hope that iMod owners (4th, 5th, and 5.5G iMod owners) will get a chance to listen to the 6G line-out and post their impressions when comparing the two (or doing shoot-outs at headfi meets) and thanks in advance for doing so.
Cheers!
Vinnie
__________________
_____________________________________________ "Remember - Audiophile friends don't let audiophile friends listen to MP3s... Only use Lossless or WAV files!" :-)
I've only spent around 1 to 2 hours of listening to these two units, but so far I already prefer the sound of the iMod 5.5G with Vcap dock... there is a little more weight in the bottom and the top-end is a little warmer/sweeter sounding. The 6G is a little thinner sounding in comparison.
I translate this to mean: iPod 6G without mod sounds almost as good as iMod 5.5G with vcap dock. Pure 6G is a "little" worse.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vinnie R.
Let me clarify this a little (just based on my findings):
The 6G iPod line-out sounds closer to the 5G/5.5G iMod with Vcap Dock than the stock 5G/5.5G line-out does, but saying "almost as good" might be going a little too far and may lead to people being disappointed.
I'm confused.
__________________ Team OAF
Amps: RSA Predator / RSA Hornet M Phones: Sennheiser HD600 / Westone UM2 / Koss KSC75 / Sennheiser CX300 Sources: iPod Touch 32GB / iPod 60GB Video / Sony SCD-CE595 / ALAC via iTunes
Current Head-Fi threat level is orange. Intelligence indicates a high risk of money being spent, but a specific target has not yet been identified.
Headphoneus Supremus Member of the Trade: Sē Audio
What I come away with is that if you plan on using an iPod stock you'll be happier with the new 6G.
If you want the best possible sound it won't quite compete with an iModded 5.5G, and it probably wouldn't yield the same benifits from Vinnie's mods, so stick with the 5.5G and wait for harddrive prices to drop.
I think what he said is that the stock 6g sounds closer to a 5g imod w/ v-caps than the stock 5g
So basically 5g imod> stock 6g> stock 5g
How much closer to the 5g imod, I can't tell based on his review.
__________________
---------------------------- Team Objectivity
---------------------------- "Sometimes I wonder if this whole scene is just some sort of a sick experiment on the power of suggestion put on by a team of sadistic psychologists." -Dept_of_Alchemy
------------------ Feedback -----------
Anyone want to come to the NC meet on September 23rd to pit my 5.5g iMod and vCap portable dock against their iPod classic using the same ALO line out dock and the Corda Move? :evil:
Also keep in mind that this comparison was done based on a 5.5 G iMod with the v-cap dock, which was reported to sound better than the 5.5G iMod with the regular iMod dock, which was reported to sound better than the 4G iMods.
Based on this, I wonder how the 6G line out stacks up against a 4G iMod.
__________________ My Former Rig (at the peak of my audioholism): 60 GB 4th Gen iMod -> ALO Cryo X Silver (Rap Around) mini-mini -> RSA Tomahawk (#T276) -> UE Triple.Fi 10 Pro (445/1000) My Current Rig (which I enjoy just as much): 80 GB 6th Gen Black iPod Classic -> UE Triple.Fi 10 Pro (445/1000) My Rotation: The Roots, Jurassic 5, John Mayer, Common, Nas, Bright Eyes, Ray Lamontagne, Wilco My Wish List: Custom Tips for Triple.Fi's
Am I to understand that you are comparing the stock 6G w/o Vcap dock, to a 5.5g iMod with the Vcap dock? If so, isn't this a little unfair since the Vcap dock will boost the sound quality of the iMod even more? How do the two compare without the Vcap dock in the equation (ie. just the ipods and an amp)? Or forgive me if I misread what you wrote.
The 6G does not have coupling caps on the output, so it is impossible for him to compare the two on even terms, unless he was to compare them both using apples native line out... at which point it has nothing to do with the Red Wine Audio mods.
I'm with swt61, the 6G sounds like a great solution if you don't want to mod your iPod. I'm pretty sure there will be lots of comparisons between the 5.5G and 6G as a 'home source' in the days to come for those who are interested in more details. Since I've moved towards a more minimal setup the 6G is definitely interesting based on its capacity and format options alone. Thanks for the technical overview Vinnie!
__________________ "For a list of all the ways technology has failed to improve the quality of life, please press three."
Moon Audio modded Original CD-2008MK-II / de Almeida Signature Shadow XLR / McAlister Audio Massive Attack / Headphile modded BlackGold recabled AKG K340 OR APureSound V3 recabled Grado RS-1
Linear Mode
