Originally Posted by Iron_Dreamer
I'm conflicted over whether or not to keep the lens. On one hand, it's supposedly the most convenient thing ever, the ultimate jack of all trades (and VR is pretty damn cool). On the other hand, I wonder if the vast majority of the pics I take (landscape, and indoor medium/low light) wouldn't be better looking with a Tokina 12-24 and Nikkor 35 F/2.
Indoor medium/low light is a tough one for this lens, especially if you have moving subjects. For that you'll want a faster lens for sure.
Not sure how often you will be filming between 12-17mm, but if not often then you may find it gives you nice landscape shots. Give it a try and let us know how it goes. Oh, and lucky you, getting a D200. If I had more spare money I would seriously consider a D200/300...... but alas.....