Head-Fi.org  ›  Forums  ›  Misc.-Category Forums  ›  Music  ›  Rolling Stones' "Sympathy for the Devil" question
All New PostsForum Nav:

Rolling Stones' "Sympathy for the Devil" question

#1
Rating: 0
Hi all,

in this song, there is a verse:

Let me please introduce myself
I'm a man of wealth and taste
And I laid traps for troubadours
Who get killed before they reached Bombay


Can anyone enlighten me as to what the highlighted words stand for? All the other allusions are obvious, but I can't crack this one. Thanks!
Team College-Fi
Home: FLAC => Foobar2K => E-MU 0404|USB => Audio-Technica ATH-A900LTD + Sennheiser HD 580
Portable: FLAC => Rockboxed iPod nano => Koss KSC-75 or SportaPro
Speaker Rig: Onkyo TX-8011 amp => Dayton BR-1 bookshelf speakers
Reply
#2
Rating: 0
I'll be glad to help you here.

You see, Bombay is a brand of whiskey and killed refers to getting drunk. Now, a "Troubador" is like a doorman, but he's drunk, see? So the guy, who's like, the devil, is laying a "trap", which is a way of saying he's trying to get through the door. So its like a "trap" that the guy's drunk - not the devil guy, the doorman guy, except he's more like a sneaky trash man than a doorman, as such. So, anyway, the guy can't get through the door, but that's really a cockney slang way of saying he's trying to drink the whiskey, which is, of course, made by Bombay.

Hope that helps....
Reply
#3
Rating: 0
Ahh...

And I was trying to somehow connect this to medieval bards/ministrels Is it just cockney slang or general term in English-speaking countries? Edit: I mean 'troubadours' referring to doormen?

Thanks a lot, btw!!!
Team College-Fi
Home: FLAC => Foobar2K => E-MU 0404|USB => Audio-Technica ATH-A900LTD + Sennheiser HD 580
Portable: FLAC => Rockboxed iPod nano => Koss KSC-75 or SportaPro
Speaker Rig: Onkyo TX-8011 amp => Dayton BR-1 bookshelf speakers
Reply
#4
Rating: 0
I've heard of Bombay gin, but never bombay wiskey.

Anyway, the two interpretations of that line that I am familar with are:

Troubadours were travelling musicians in the middle ages who would travel from France trying to reach out to Europe and Asia of Gods true message but were often killed by Church officials or others before they could finish thier journey.

or,

Some say troubadours refer to The Beatles. They became mystical in their song writing after going to India, losing touch with reality and the commom man.

I don't what, if anything, they meant. I assume it was some allusion to something the devil did somewhere sometime... Good song though
Reply
#5
Rating: 0
I could be way off base here, but it could be a reference to the Thuggee religious cult in India. The Thuggees would ritually strangle travellers they caught in the Indian countryside. It is believed that they were responsible for millions of deaths. The Thuggees believed that each death would prevent the goddess Kali from returning for 1000 years. I'd guess that keeping her away would be a good thing! The British suffered their share of deaths, and by the end of the 19th century, had crushed the movement.

Maybe I missed it. The European involvement in India goes back a long way!

Edit: European involvement in India does go back a long way, but Bombay was a creation of the British, so it had to be during the time of the Raj.

The one thing that can solve most of our problems is dancing

- James Brown
____________________________________________
Team Sennessandro

Reply
#6
Rating: 0
Thank you everyone!

I actually needed it for a class... prof said he was looking for the answer for some years now. I'll present him with all these (very plausible) theories. If anyone else has stuff to add, I'll be grateful
Team College-Fi
Home: FLAC => Foobar2K => E-MU 0404|USB => Audio-Technica ATH-A900LTD + Sennheiser HD 580
Portable: FLAC => Rockboxed iPod nano => Koss KSC-75 or SportaPro
Speaker Rig: Onkyo TX-8011 amp => Dayton BR-1 bookshelf speakers
Reply
#7
Rating: 0
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vicious Tyrant
I'll be glad to help you here.

You see, Bombay is a brand of whiskey and killed refers to getting drunk. Now, a "Troubador" is like a doorman, but he's drunk, see? So the guy, who's like, the devil, is laying a "trap", which is a way of saying he's trying to get through the door. So its like a "trap" that the guy's drunk - not the devil guy, the doorman guy, except he's more like a sneaky trash man than a doorman, as such. So, anyway, the guy can't get through the door, but that's really a cockney slang way of saying he's trying to drink the whiskey, which is, of course, made by Bombay.

Hope that helps....
No offense, but you're kidding, right? As far as I know there is no such thing as Bombay whiskey and a troubadour is certainly not like a doorman.

"If the elevator tries to bring you down, go crazy! Punch a higher floor!'

Reply
#8
Rating: 0
Also, when he rode a tank, did the devil hold a generous rank, or a general's rank?
"Ah, It's time to relax and you know what that means; a glass of wine, your favorite easy chair, and of course, this compact disc playing on your home stereo. So go on and indulge yourself, thats right, kick off your shoes, put your feet up, lean back and just enjoy the melodies. After all, 'Music...
Reply
#9
Rating: 0
Quote:
Originally Posted by dknightd
Troubadours were travelling musicians in the middle ages who would travel from France trying to reach out to Europe and Asia of Gods true message but were often killed by Church officials or others before they could finish thier journey.
Any idea why Church officials would want to prevent the spread of Christianity to Asia?

The Compact Disc Digital Audio System offers the best possible sound reproduction - on a small, convenient disc. Its remarkable performance is the result of a unique combination of digital storage and laser optics.

Reply
#10
Rating: 0
Quote:
Originally Posted by viator122
Any idea why Church officials would want to prevent the spread of Christianity to Asia?
Maybe because the troubadour's understanding of "God's true message" was in contradiction to the official party line represented by the church authorities
Reply
#11
Rating: 0
Quote:
Originally Posted by zotjen
No offense, but you're kidding, right? As far as I know there is no such thing as Bombay whiskey and a troubadour is certainly not like a doorman.
Well there is Bombay gin (Wikipedia has it). The troubadour = doorman bit is a bit puzzling, hence I asked again (maybe I'm just not smelling sarcasm or something )
Team College-Fi
Home: FLAC => Foobar2K => E-MU 0404|USB => Audio-Technica ATH-A900LTD + Sennheiser HD 580
Portable: FLAC => Rockboxed iPod nano => Koss KSC-75 or SportaPro
Speaker Rig: Onkyo TX-8011 amp => Dayton BR-1 bookshelf speakers
Reply
#12
Rating: 0
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ahriman4891
Thank you everyone!

I actually needed it for a class... prof said he was looking for the answer for some years now. I'll present him with all these (very plausible) theories. If anyone else has stuff to add, I'll be grateful
Oh, hey, dude - please don't add my answer to your college paper. I was totally kidding, its all gibberish. I should have added a smiley. I'm an ass.
Reply
#13
Rating: 0
Quote:
Originally Posted by zotjen
No offense, but you're kidding, right? As far as I know there is no such thing as Bombay whiskey and a troubadour is certainly not like a doorman.
No offense taken and yes, totally kidding.

There is no Bombay whiskey (that I know of) and troubador is, indeed, nothing like a doorman or a sneaky trash man, whatever that means. I was shooting for a humorous Jim Anchower-kind of loser, stoner sounding response. It seemed funny to me until I realized the OP was doing research for his college paper.
Reply
#14
Rating: 0
Such a great Stone's number - perhaps the best in my taste. Brings a lot of memories back.
A truth only last till something else is more true. /Glod

- - - I don't log on often these days. Please e-mail me for my attention - - -
Reply
#15
Rating: 0
One other theory. Christianity was often spread by traveling groups who had musicians in them who would literally sing gods praises. (the revivals in the american south are a direct descendent of that)

Well certainly the christians face some resistance in a country like India with hindus and so forth.

So literally it could be another group offing the christians in the name of religion
Reply
All New PostsForum Nav:
  Back to Forum: Music
  Return Home
Head-Fi.org  ›  Forums  ›  Misc.-Category Forums  ›  Music  ›  Rolling Stones' "Sympathy for the Devil" question